The URL can be used to link to this page

Item 6BCITY OF SOUTHLAKE Department of Planning & Development Services March 31, 2015 CASE NO: ZA15-002 PROJECT: Zoning Change and Development Plan for Carillon EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Hines/GTIS Carillon, LLC is requesting a Zoning Change and Development Plan for Carillon on property described as Lots 1-11 Block 23, Lots 1-16 Block 24, and Lots 1- 16 Block 6 of Carillon Phase 1A and all of Carillon Phase 4A, Carillon Phase 4B, Carillon Phase 4C, Carillon Phase 5A, Carillon Phase 5B, and Carillon Phase 5C, City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas located mainly north of E. Kirkwood Boulevard between N. White Chapel Blvd. and N. Carroll Ave. and south of Estes Park subdivision in Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: "ECZ" — Employment Center Zoning District. Requested Zoning: "ECZ"—Employment Center Zoning District. SPIN Neighborhood # 3. REQUEST DETAILS: The purpose of this request is to amend the current Carillon Zoning Book to add a roofing material permitted in the EC Neighborhood - Chateaux District. The proposal adds language to allow metal as a permitted roof material to Chateaux District. Since the March 17, 2015 City Council meeting, the applicant has further defined the type metal roof material to be permitted. This is shown in the paragraph below: In Section 7.0 Architectural Controls- Residential (Chateaux) page 102 is revised to include: ■ Architectural Materials- Roof: Slate, Synthetic Slate, minimum 30-year composite shingle (or greater), tile or synthetic tile or metal, with non-metallic, matte finish. in acceotable muted earth tones of browns. tans and arays. The roof material may not be flat and must adhere to the detail attached. Metal must have a .galvanized thickness level of G90. Ultimate approval of color and material rests with the ARC. followed by the aoorova/ of the citv for the permit. See Attachment C, pages 6-9 The applicant has stated that the metal material is only being requested for the home sites within the Chateaux District and not in the Villas District. There are 232 lots in the Chateaux District. The applicant's justification for the request is provided in the attached narrative. See Attachment C, page 1. ACTION NEEDED: 1) Conduct a Public Hearing 2) Consider the Request ATTACHMENTS: (A) Background Information (B) Vicinity Map (C) Plans and Support Information - Link to Presentation (D) Zoning Change and Development Plan Review Summary No. 2 (E) Surrounding Property Owners Map Case No. Attachment A ZA15-002 Page 1 (F) Surrounding Property Owner Responses (G) Full Size Plans (for Commission and Council Members Only) STAFF CONTACT: Ken Baker 817-748-8067 Patty Moos 817-748-8269 Case No. Attachment A ZA15-002 Page 2 BACKGROUND INFORMATION OWNER: Hines/GTIS Carillon, LLC APPLICANT: Hines/GTIS Carillon, LLC PROPERTY SITUATION: The property is located at the northeast corner of SH 114 and N. White Chapel Boulevard. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: Lots 1-12 Block 23, Lots 1-16 Block 24, and Lots 1-16 Block 6 of Carillon Phase 1A and all of Carillon Phase 4A, Carillon Phase 4B, Carillon Phase 4C, Carillon Phase 5A, Carillon Phase 5B, and Carillon Phase 5C, City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas. LAND USE CATEGORY: Mixed Use CURRENT ZONING: ECZ — Employment Center Zoning District REQUESTED ZONING: ECZ — Employment Center Zoning District HISTORY: May 20, 1997; City Council approved a zoning change and concept plan to "NR-PUD" Non -Residential Planned Unit Development. December 18, 2001; City Council approved a zoning change and concept plan requiring a 300 ft. setback on N. Carroll Avenue, subject to City Council discretion. The purpose of the zoning change and concept plan was to incorporate newly acquired tracts of land into the existing "NR-PUD", revise parcel boundaries and permitted uses within the district. November 18, 2008; City Council approved a Zoning Change and Development Plan for the Carillon development. September 4, 2012; City Council approved the request to amend miscellaneous development regulations in the Carillon Zoning Booklet. SOUTHLAKE 2030: Consolidated Land Use Plan The underlying land use designation is Mixed Use and the proposed EE development is consistent with the �- designated land use. Typically, the Mixed Use designation is intended for _ medium- to higher -intensity office buildings, hotels, commercial activities, _ retail centers, and residential uses. Nuisance -free, wholly enclosed light manufacturing and assembly uses that have no outdoor storage are permitted if _ designed to be compatible with adjacent uses. Other suitable activities are those � permitted in the Public Parks/Open , Space, Public/Semi-Public, Low Density Residential, Medium Density Case No. Attachment A ZA15-002 Page 1 Residential, Retail Commercial, and Office Commercial categories previously discussed. PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION: January 22, 2015; Approved (7-0) the motion to table until the February 5, 2015 Planning and Zoning Commission meeting. February 5, 2015; A motion to deny did not carry with a vote of (3-3); A motion to approve the item as presented removing the words "standing seam" (from the proposed metal roof description) was approved (4-2). Vice Chairman Parrish and Commissioner Forman dissented. CITY COUNCIL: February 17, 2015; Approved (7-0) the motion for the applicant's request to table until the March 3, 2015 City Council meeting. March 3, 2015; Approved (7-0) the motion for the applicant's request to table until the March 17, 2015 March 17, 2015; Approved (7-0 ) the motion for the applicant's request to table until the April 7, 2015 City Council meeting. STAFF COMMENTS: The Zoning and Development Review Summary #2 is located in Attachment D. WCommunity DevelopmenWEMO12015 CasesO02 - ZDP - CarillonlStaff Report Case No. Attachment A ZA15-002 Page 2 ME! 5 PLANS AND SUPPORT INFORMATION Previously Proposed Narrative 2-17-15 PURPOSE AND INTENT (Revised for City Council) 2/10/2015 Re: Carillon Architectural Amendment to Ordinance 480-564, 11/18/2008 Addition of one roof material Hines is requesting a change to the roofing materials in our design guidelines affecting a small portion of the +/- 285 acres Hines tract ("Carillon") located at the northwest corner of State Highway 114 and White Chapel Boulevard. Carillon is divided into two districts, divided by Kirkwood Blvd, The Village District and Chateaux District. This addition will not affect the "Village District". the Villas. The Villa guidelines will continue to require all homes to be "French" in architecture. This material change is only being requested for The Chateaux District, and would potentially affect a very small percentage of the remaining homes yet to be designed. Per the original zoning ordinance, "The Chateaux District is a mix of architectural styles providing a diverse and vibrant mix of home choices per page 80 of the approved zoningAll design guidelines for the Chateaux's will remain in place with the only change in Section 7.0 Architectural controls — residential — materials. The addition would be inserted into the paragraph outlining roof materials which currently reads : "Slate, Synthetic Slate, minimum 30 year composite shingle (or greater),tile, or synthetic the*. Shingle colors must be approved by the ACC". The addition would be inserted at the asterisk above: ...or "metal, with non metallic, matte finish, with accepted muted colors in earth tones of browns, tans and grays. All roof material colors must be approved by the ACC." Metal roofs are found on many area homes in neighborhoods such as Vaquero, Terra Bella and Shady Oaks. It should be noted metal roofs are a premium roof material, three times more costly than a quality installation of a shingle roof and the most energy efficient material compared to tile or shingles. Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 1 Energy Savings with Cool Metal Roofing i Metal Roofing Alliance'1... http-.'Iwww metalroofing.com/v2fcontentiguide/costs/energy-saYings.Cfm Are you a Frotessional? ftrofessiwals) Login: Members (101seeureWoglr,) i Forums(fv2fforumslindex.cim?admn=mtlDafd.menlbefs) Search METAL ROOFING PRODUCT GALLERY ASK THE EXPERTS FIND A CONTRACTOR from A to Zinc Photos Metal Roofing Forum Near your home (N21contenurnetal-rootingr) (1v21contenVphctcgaIIery/) (/v2iforums) VvOconlenufaco Metal Roofing A-Zine ( vv—tantrmetal- aringl) Reduce Engery, Costs Energy Savings with Coo{ Meta[ Roofing More and more, homeowners are seeking out energy -swing bunding materials for their renovations and new homes, products that not only secure and improve structures but also provide long-term cast -cutting on energy bills while promoting environmental and economic sustalnabilily in the greater community. Among the array of possible upgrades, 'cool metal roofing" easily answers this consumer demand offering a solid, attractive roofing solution available in multiple colors. textures, and profiles, for steep -slope and low -slope applications, that can save your household up to 40% of its annual energy costs, depending on your geographical region. The Benefits of Energy Efficient Metal Roofing Did you know white -painted metal roofing has the highest solar reflectance value of any roofing product available and can save you up to 40% of your annual energy bills? As reported by the Cool Metal Roofing Coalition and the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, installation of reflective metal roofing can save your home up to 40% in summer cooling energy costs while highly emissive metal roofs can reduce urban air temperatures by as much as 12' F. Combined, these benefits mean less money out of your wallet, less dependence on energy resources and less general air pollution in your neighborhood and across the nation. EnerggA Ing Rellactno R. Emlaslve bark Asphah Roof Metal Root Surface MetalRoarsuit.- While asphalt traps heat... Metal Roofs reflect solar energy... And pigments re -emit heat. The secret to metal roofing's energy savings is in its variety of finishes. As shown above, the basic, unpainted metal root will reflect much of the solar radiation usually absorbed In your attic and home by an asphalt roof. But, for homes in warmer climates, pre -painted or granular coated metal roofing systems not only reflect solar energy but also coot your home by re -emitting most of ,.vhat solar radiation is absorbod.Whero annual cooling loads dominate, a highly reflective and highly emissive painted or granular -coated metal roof is optimal for reducing energy consumption and can actually re -emit up to 90% of absorbed solar radiation. Additionally, most metal roofing, including standing seam, is composed of recycled meters, and can be installed directly onto an existing asphalt roof, reducing landfill waste and promoting quick installation as well as dacadas of environmentallysound, maintenance -free strength and beauty. Curious about the best energy -saving metal ruofing for your area? Use our online Meta, Roofing Manufacturer Guide (1v21contentymanufacturer1) to compare available finishes or even find a Metal Roofing Contractor (lv2lcontentifeci) in your area! More Savings Opportunitiest Homes upgraded with quality metal roofing typically see costs recouped at more than three quarters ofthe Job cost! Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 2 i Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 3 Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 4 102 Carillon Zoning Book (page 102) 2-17-15 Slroadard ECE49 EC VeigfhborAeed VdIsIfDafriC1 ChrW:ix Drstrrrl 7.0 Architectural COatrols - Residential i{AD Ckehmnx • Prohibited Wmdmv m wall type air-oDnditia em No radio or teki Ldm aerial woes or mlemas shall be Items msiw, on the outsdeofawbwilding_Satellnedishes,ImitedtotwawyCMinchesmdummtn are permitted" No taxpo=y dn•rrue cf arty kmd_ Na reoaoval of dirt fmm a lot unless; for the ry s ctimofapooLNcdn1inuirrmniagoperations.AnimalsampermdtIed(optotbree(3)adult annals}, prOvrdBd Ihey ate oat kept fbr bMB&ag Or c=Mffual purposes. ..laterlsls • Fagade Mm of 39%of tba building fagade mmt berovewd in Min of 85% of the baildiag &gzde 1®st be m--v me —I eachldmg woad—s, door, too# and c--Ni in --OW mateltal, —h drag glass. No mace dam two (2)pnmarycladding wi� door, rant; mdgla99. Na more mauTalcshall beused asprimary claddisg. NO mote 1 e two (2)primzrY cladding mwaink &an 25% of homes all use stucco as the pranuy shell be used as pomrarjr ckddm& No more daddmg meleoel and nn more than two coosaci=,E then 25% of homes vnH use stucco x me homes maybe cansuucted of stucco. primarp cladding material and no more than two crosec fn%homes may be mnstrortnd ofstucco. • Mwauy Huck: brick v mBer, stone, cast Mum, gim fiber Hurt, bndi veneer, starte, cast stone, glass Materials reinforced conaete, glass fiber reireed gypmm/7 fiber rein%road UMCT - glass fiber tethered coTM*oro pame:Ls, shirca, and split face reiafm€ed gypsana, tnt=A mnrrnln cmrrele masonry units_ No 13TFS allmmc panels, stocoo, and split fire €onaew masamT units. No HIPS allawEmL ® Roof MAIP, SYUdWtLC State, ZZrjU3UM 30 9r C0133paMM Slate, syzrthoftc SUM, UMUJUXOM30 yr shm ( _ j, c (or oDlor must be appzavedby the ACC symbeaLtRe. Scalorra=be aMm%dbytbedLCC • PrAil led Unfinished om mOmbmed macrete masonry, rood Unfinmtmd or uMedised €matte masomry, Matwrialc sidmgpleffldx�viagkarmem]sidimg9,HII1S wood sifng:pbmfir,tiinyl,ormeml�idiags EIFS • VUndaws U mdows en f mw etwom nor sisibla from sweet will Windom on from eleuatioo or vtsrble from he wood, vbuA cz amm®m clad with eateriar grid streetuill be wood, vinyl, or allaaiam divider or..mnrme. RefleottveuiadawcavErmg5 are chduithestesWr gnd divides armmtms. not pamuded. RaFlxriw wind= caves are not • Garaggs All garages viewed R t the street or commm area All garages viewed from the ff a or must have a wood door. Ports €adheres unot be Common area must have: a sod door. Porte approved in writ'mg bry the AOC_ f.rhw.w must be approved in westing by the eiCC. • Doors Flbergla99 amd pta9ud are art permMaL AIL doors Fiber and plastic are oat pemtitmd m= be approved by the DRC and+or AOC b EbFe All doors mast be apprmredby the DRC iaamlloti,m sndfnr ACC befooa ms llarim • CI®ney All chit>mey or fireplace a mlosures shall be 1005E All chmmney cr fireplace mclo9ues shm0 he bna,back veneu, sWioe Mme— mTMveww 100%la l,bQick venew, sWae Mom- mnswu tun or Shld€U_ Chimneys located On an ma9mi]Veneu Lonstr ohma or 5i7CO0_ elderierwall omst be 100%bri€k ar stare Chiomey9 lacatBd on an exterior vrall must be 100%llri€k or stone_ • _ 'a:l'� : -w; __ S.D single family ]Comes are rBglta A in have cast " All 9m* fumly homes are regained to n,ailbms approved by the ACC. have cast iron mailboxes agprOved by the ACC • CTutters Shall beahimmum<andpemledtoaccewbuddmg Shagbealummumandpamtedtoaccent and Mown facades, copper, orgalruri d Orpadntedsteel hmlding facades capper, orgnh%mzed or o ri3punted. sleet. Nam: AR Amhimetnral Controls are subject m DRE approval prior tqtbe Gnat sae plan and For final plat approvals. Slate, Synthetic Slate, minimum 30 yr. composite shingles (or greater), tile or synthetic tile or metal, with non-metallic, matte finish, in muted colors of browns, tans and grays. All colors must be approved by the ACC Adopted 18.November.2008 Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 5 Revised Narrative March 27, 2015 PURPOSE AND INTENT (Revised for City Council) 4/7/2015 Re: Carillon Architectural Amendment to Ordinance 480-564, 11/18/2008 Addition of metal roof material Hines is requesting a change to the roofing materials in our design guidelines affecting a small portion of the +/- 285 acres Hines tract ("Carillon") located at the northwest corner of State Highway 114 and White Chapel Boulevard. Carillon is divided into two districts, divided by Kirkwood Blvd: The Village District (172 homes) Design is 100% French Renaissance in three sizes Villa A 47'-110' Villa B 50' x 110' Villa C 65' x 120'+ The Chateaux District (232 homes1 Design is a Mix of Architectural Styles in three sizes Chateaux 90' x 130' or 140' Estate 100' x 155' —170' Lake 120' x 160' This roof material will NOT affect the Village District roofs. The Villa guidelines require and will continue to require all homes to be "French" in architecture. This material change is only being requested for The Chateaux District, and would potentially affect only the homes yet to be designed and ultimately approved by the ARC and City of Southlake. All initial home designs for every lot will be reviewed against these guidelines by the developer responsible, in this case, Hines. Per the original zoning ordinance on page 80: "The Chateaux District is a mix of architectural styles providing a diverse and vibrant mix of home choices. All design guidelines for the Chateaux's will remain in place with one change in Section 7.0 Architectural controls — residential — materials. The guideline currently reads: "Slate, Synthetic Slate, minimum 30 year composite shingle (or greater),tile, or synthetic the*. Shingle colors must be approved by the ACC". The addition would be inserted at the asterisk above: ...or "metal, with non metallic, matte finish, in accepted muted colors in earth tones of browns, tans and grays. The metal roof material may not be flat and must adhere to the detail attached. Metal must have a galvanized thickness level of G90. Ultimate approval of color and material rests with the ARC, followed by the approval of the city for permit. See attachment 3 for further details. Metal roofs are found on area homes in neighborhoods such as Vaquero, Terra Bella and Shady Oaks. Metal roofs are a premium roof material, more costly than a quality installation of a shingle roof and provide more energy efficient material compared to tile or shingles. The builder and roofing company will have specifics on this comparison, as well as samples at the council meeting. Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 6 Metal roofs used to look like they belonged on sheds or barns, or commercial in appearance. Today metal roofing products are available to fit residential architectural styles. Metal roofs are now made with the following: • Fade -resistant colors, concealed fasteners • Concealed fasteners for a cleaner look • Maintenance free, will not rust, crack or rot • Resistant to streaking and staining and never needs cleaning HOA Meetine There were 23 oppositions to standing seam roofs at the last council meeting. A few Villa owners were opposed (which is their right) to standing seam roof material and went door to door asking neighbors to complete the form and send to P/Z and Council. Information was also posted on the neighborhood website by homeowners. Unintentionally the complete details were not communicated specifically enough. To try and reverse this miscommunication, we are holding for Carillon Homeowners, and have sent an HOA eblast, as well as the same notice on the neighborhood website run by the homeowners. The meeting is scheduled for April I" from 4:30 — 6:30 pm. Hines associates, Builders, Architects and a roofing expert will be on hand to answer any questions or concerns related to this issue. It is Hines' goal to be certain all Carillon Homeowners are informed prior to the April 71h council meeting. It is also our promise to complete the development with the same quality and high standard we have exhibited thus far. We want to build a strong neighborhood with a vibrant HOA. Carillon is a crown jewel for Hines and we hope will become the same for the City of Southlake and its homeowners. Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 7 Attachment 1 Example of Village District Villas Attachment 2 Example of Chateaux District Homes currently built or under development Case No. Httacnment C ZA015-002 Page 8 Attachment 2 Example of Carillon Chateaux District Homes either completed or under construction Ilkin 11W . Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 9 Attachment 3 — supplement to the metal roof guidelines: Residential standing seam - panels with an attachment flange hidden by the next panel. Attachment point must be covered by the adjacent panel. For panels over 20 feet in length, hidden moveable clips must be attached to the roof deck and the seam of the roof panel. Modular Press -formed panels-prepainted - Modular Press -formed prepainted interlocking panels with standard dimensions and shapes. May resemble wood shake, tile, slate or shingles. The roof panels are attached with hidden fasteners directly to the roof deck. Must be 4-way interlocking. Modular Press -formed Granular Coated Modular Press -Formed granular coated dimension panels t either thru-fastened or attached with hidden fasteners and coated with an acrylic coating with embedded stone granules on the surface. The panels may be installed over a batten/counter batten wood grid system or directly to the roof deck. Case No. Attachment C ZA015-002 Page 10 ZONING & DEVELOPMENT PLAN REVIEW SUMMARY Review No.: Two Date of Review: 1/15/15 Project Name: Zoning and Development Plan — Carillon Southlake APPLICANT: Hines/GTI Denise McCormick 1845 Riviera Lane Southlake, TX 76092 P: 817-251-5900 E: denise.mccormick@hines.com Owner: Hines/ GTIS Denise McCormick 1845 Riviera Lane Southlake, TX 76092 P: 817-251-5900 E: denise.mccormick@hines.com CITY STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE ABOVE REFERENCED PROJECT RECEIVED BY THE CITY ON 12/29/2014 AND WE OFFER THE FOLLOWING STIPULATIONS. THESE STIPULATIONS ARE HEREBY MADE CONDITIONS OF SITE PLAN APPROVAL UNLESS SPECIFICALLY AMENDED BY THE CITY COUNCIL. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR NEED FURTHER CLARIFICATION, PLEASE CONTACT THE APPROPRIATE STAFF MEMBER. Planning Review Patty Moos Planner I Phone: (817) 748-8269 Email: pmoos(cD-ci.southlake.tx.us 1. Provide all the pages from the Carillon Zoning Book related to the proposed changes with redlined strikeouts or similar method that easily shows (graphically) the revisions and /or additions to the zoning book. Case No. Attachment D ZA15-002 Page 1 Surrounding Property Owners Carillon Southlake S DR ��''�a�DEL40ROIX DR �� Es m� 717 SPO # 1. ��-wne-rW Fisher, Jeffrey Etux Victoria zo-MM� RPUD Address 618 CASTLE ROCK DR Acreage 0.43 -R� NR 2. Thrasher, Wesley Etux Terrie AG 1975 N WHITE CHAPEL BLVD 1.18 NR 3. Cercone, Albert B AG 1900 N CARROLL AVE 0.27 NR 4. Maranan, Bernadette Etvir V SF1-A 1101 DEL MAR DR 0.99 NR 5. Knapp, Dewitt L III SF1-A 1105 DEL MAR DR 1.02 NR 6. Martzen, Ernst M Etux Elaine AG 1100 PRIMROSE LN 0.20 NR 7. Nguyen, Ashley Etvir Cuong Duc SF1-A 1100 BAY MEADOWS DR 1.01 NR 8. Toups, Tommie Etux Sharon SF1-A 1104 BAY MEADOWS DR 0.99 NR 9. Hight, Lance B SF1-A 1709 N CARROLL AVE 1.13 NR 10. Ensenberger, C J & Elaine P SF1-A 1505 N CARROLL AVE 2.42 NR 11. Lay, Robert Etux Jennie SF1-A 1515 N CARROLL AVE 1.62 NR 12. Esquivel, Indalecio SF1-A 1525 N CARROLL AVE 1.92 NR 13. Chodavadia, Bharatkum B Etux SF1-A 1025 CARROLL MEADOWS CT 1.06 NR 14. Bunnell, Rex W Etux Gina SF30 1090 PRIMROSE LN 0.97 NR 15. Smiley, Gregory & Janet SF20A 1086 PRIMROSE LN 0.62 NR 16. Litaker, Janice Etvir Casey G SF20A 1080 PRIMROSE LN 0.35 NR 17. Fore, Stan Etux Lisa SF1-A 1101 BAY MEADOWS DR 0.97 NR 18. Birchfield, Sandra E AG 1715 N CARROLL AVE 0.80 NR 19. Ciesielski, Bradley Etux Lisa SF20A 1030 PRIMROSE LN 0.49 NR 20. Windham, Greg SF1-A 1015 CARROLL MEADOWS CT 1.01 NR 21. Palmer, Steven G Etux Casey S SF20A 1060 PRIMROSE LN 0.49 NR 22. Martzen, Ernst M Etux Elaine AG 1100 PRIMROSE LN 0.41 NR 23. Scott, Donald Etux Gala SF1-A 1045 CARROLL MEADOWS CT 0.99 NR 24. Dillard, Brenda SF1-A 1035 CARROLL MEADOWS CT 1.06 NR Case No. ZA15-002 Attachment E Page 1 25. Brentwood Residential Assoc SF30 120 BRENTWOOD CIR 0.23 NR 26. Knezek, Stacie RPUD 2104 BEAVER CREEK LN 0.36 NR 27. Patel, Nirav Etux Payalben RPUD 2108 BEAVER CREEK LN 0.37 NR 28. Schleif, John E Etux Jana SF30 113 BRENTWOOD CIR 0.95 NR 29. Pailes, Nathan A SF30 108 BRENTWOOD CIR 0.66 NR 30. Simpson, Charles Etux Kathleen SF30 104 BRENTWOOD CIR 0.68 NR 31. Conley, Michael Etux Audrey SF30 100 BRENTWOOD CIR 0.74 NR 32. Southlake, City Of ECZ 100 E KIRKWOOD BLVD 0.63 NR 33. Windsor Homes Cumberland Llc ECZ 216 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 34. Ascencio, Cristobal SF30 112 BRENTWOOD CIR 0.65 NR 35. Brown, Kenneth R Sr Etux C J SF1-A 2005 N WHITE CHAPEL BLVD 1.71 NR 36. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 108 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.41 NR 37. Thrasher, Wesley Etux Terri AG 1965 N WHITE CHAPEL BLVD 1.85 NR 38. Stewart, Kristopher & Stephani ECZ 100 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.39 NR 39. Windsor Homes Cumberland Llc ECZ 104 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 40. Cline, Keith A Jr Etux Stephan SF30 116 BRENTWOOD CIR 0.87 NR 41. Windsor Homes Cumberland LIc ECZ 208 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 42. Sharma, Gagan RPUD 2100 BEAVER CREEK LN 0.44 NR 43. Gillen, Robert Etux Wenjuan RPUD 301 BOULDER DR 0.34 NR 44. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 212 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 45. Uddin, Mohammad N & A Igbal RPUD 305 BOULDER DR 0.36 NR 46. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 300 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.37 NR 47. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 308 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.38 NR 48. Windsor Homes Cumberland Llc ECZ 304 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 49. Esparza, Lisa C RPUD 645 BOULDER DR 0.36 NR 50. Johnson, Jay B RPUD 641 BOULDER DR 0.36 NR 51. Jack, Hayden RPUD 637 BOULDER DR 0.41 NR 52. Ramos, Jo A Etux Cintia Y ECZ 504 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.39 NR 53. Koganti, Ramakrishna P Etux Ma RPUD 633 BOULDER DR 0.39 NR 54. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc/ Arizaga de Moreno, Maria and Claudio Moreno ECZ 500 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 0 55. Chamakura, Sanjayant R RPUD 517 BOULDER DR 0.36 NR 56. Grumbos, Peter C Etux Janet D RPUD 629 BOULDER DR 0.37 NR 57. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 420 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 58. Baker, Jenice Etvir Robert ECZ 424 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 59. Hick, Ryan W Etux Amy E Hick RPUD 505 BOULDER DR 0.37 NR 60. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 416 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 61. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 408 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 62. K Hovanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 412 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 63. Hussain, Altaf Etux Ayesha RPUD 501 BOULDER DR 0.40 NR 64. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 400 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.39 NR 65. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 404 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 66. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 105 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.37 NR 67. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 101 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.37 NR 68. Satani, Dhaval D ECZ 209 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 69. Walker, Andrew T Etux Katie ECZ 213 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 70. Marinelli, Rodney Etux Barbara ECZ 301 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 2 71. Crane, Mary E ECZ 305 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 72. Depa, Anilkumar Etux Sindhoori ECZ 309 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 73. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 313 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 74. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 401 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 75. Claudio Moreno Revocable Trust ECZ 405 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 0 76. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 409 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 77. Reimer, Conway Etux Jennifer ECZ 413 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 78. Hughes, Christopher ECZ 417 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 79. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 421 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 80. Hardy, Micki ECZ 425 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.36 NR 81. Dharani, Rajendra Etux Prashan RPUD 313 BOULDER DR 0.37 NR 82. Santiago, James Etux Mari Toni RPUD 509 BOULDER DR 0.36 NR 83. Kanneganti, Chandra Etux Manju RPUD 513 BOULDER DR 0.35 NR 84. Mohsin, Shamim Etux Rita M RPUD 309 BOULDER DR 0.35 NR 85. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 200 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.65 NR 86. Kurp, Gary R & Denise D ECZ 204 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.38 NR 87. Bojorquez, Wm 0 & Georgina B ECZ 508 ST. TROPEZ DR 0.40 NR 88. Barley, Stephen W Etux Shaun L ECZ 1809 MONET DR 0.27 NR 89. Southlake, City Of ECZ 500 MONTE CARLO DR 0.43 NR 90. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 451 ORLEANS DR 0.09 NR 91. Atwood, Michelle Etvir Jon ECZ 1801 MONET DR 0.24 NR 92. Current Owner ECZ 1805 MONET DR 0.18 NR 93. Hardy, Micki ECZ 1800 MONET DR 0.27 NR 94. Shirey, Michael D & Denise E ECZ 1801 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.24 0 95. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 351 ORLEANS DR 0.16 NR 96. Neal, Dwayne & Dana Neal ECZ 1817 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.20 0 97. Rose, Scott R Etux Mary B Rose ECZ 1813 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.18 NR 98. Sutherland, Kenneth Etux K ECZ 1809 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.18 0 99. Brown, William D III Etux Lisa ECZ 1805 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.18 NR 100. Haworth, Dan P & Lynda S ECZ 1812 MONET DR 0.24 NR 101. Brynmar Capital Llc ECZ 1808 MONET DR 0.21 NR 102. Eager, John ECZ 1804 MONET DR 0.19 NR 103. Husain, Asif Etux Tehmina ECZ 1801 RIVIERA LN 0.14 NR 104. Mock, Brian & Maria Mock ECZ 500 ORLEANS DR 0.29 NR 105. Hines-Gtis Carillon Llc ECZ 1845 RIVIERA LN 0.14 NR 106. Jbgl Model Fund 1 Llc ECZ 1841 RIVIERA LN 0.12 NR 107. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 1837 RIVIERA LN 0.12 NR 108. Guthrie, Jacqueline Etux Ryan ECZ 1833 RIVIERA LN 0.12 0 109. Shepherd, John Etux Laura ECZ 1829 RIVIERA LN 0.12 NR 110. Schoenfeld, Steve Etux Ann Mar ECZ 1825 RIVIERA LN 0.12 NR 111. Lee, Erving Etux L Merriman ECZ 1821 RIVIERA LN 0.12 0 112. Plimpton, Thomas E Etux Kathle ECZ 1817 RIVIERA LN 0.12 NR 113. Benoit, Robert Etux Susan ECZ 1813 RIVIERA LN 0.12 0 114. Flury, Jane ECZ 1809 RIVIERA LN 0.13 NR 115. Clark, James C Etux Bria ECZ 1805 RIVIERA LN 0.13 NR 116. Michelsen, Robin M & Stacey M ECZ 1800 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.20 NR 117. Alexander, Jeffery A Etux M R ECZ 1804 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.20 NR 118. Elieson, John C Etux Kristine ECZ 1808 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.18 NR Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 3 119. Alford, Carl S & Marylee ECZ 1812 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.18 NR 120. Patel, Paresh EtuxTrusa ECZ 1816 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.18 NR 121. Martin, Margaret ECZ 1820 ST. PHILIP AVE 0.26 NR 122. Patrick Custom Homes Inc ECZ 304 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 123. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 433 MONTE CARLO DR 0.10 NR 124. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 429 MONTE CARLO DR 0.18 NR 125. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 425 MONTE CARLO DR 0.18 NR 126. Steen, Michael Etux Maria ECZ 421 MONTE CARLO DR 0.18 F 127. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 417 MONTE CARLO DR 0.18 NR 128. Sanghavi, Abhishek Etux Monika ECZ 413 MONTE CARLO DR 0.18 NR 129. Sepeda, Steven Etux Dayle A ECZ 409 MONTE CARLO DR 0.18 NR 130. Woolsey, Matthew R Etux Anne ECZ 405 MONTE CARLO DR 0.18 NR 131. Courtney, Daniel & J Courtney ECZ 401 MONTE CARLO DR 0.19 0 132. Iluyomade, Olakunle RPUD 2101 CANYON PARK DR 0.39 NR 133. Mitchell, Ronnie RPUD 312 BOULDER DR 0.39 NR 134. Chapman, Jon Etux Amy RPUD 2101 BOULDER CT 0.45 NR 135. Reddy, Sruthi Etvir A Admal RPUD 2100 BOULDER CT 0.38 NR 136. Shahidi, Hassan Etux Lori RPUD 304 BOULDER DR 0.38 NR 137. Avirneni, Sambasiva Etux Usha RPUD 308 BOULDER DR 0.34 F 138. Baldwin, Richard T Etux Gwen RPUD 700 BOULDER DR 0.42 NR 139. Marso, Steven P Etux Janet R M RPUD 2001 VAIL RD 0.47 NR 140. Smart, John B III Etux Kristi RPUD 2000 ESTES PARK DR 0.44 NR 141. Madhani, Shafique RPUD 900 SILVERTON ST 0.65 NR 142. Johnson, Robert Etux Elizabeth RPUD 904 SILVERTON ST 0.59 NR 143. Riley, Tony A Jr & Billie Jo RPUD 908 SILVERTON ST 0.62 NR 144. Estes Park Hoa RPUD 2101 CHEYENNE PARK LN 3.00 NR 145. Fuller, George A Etux Beckey P RPUD 912 SILVERTON ST 0.55 NR 146. Estes Park Hmo Assoc Inc RPUD 825 SILVERTON ST 0.86 NR 147. Garcia, Juan J Etux Jana RPUD 809 SILVERTON ST 0.38 NR 148. Kim, Seung Hyun RPUD 801 SILVERTON ST 0.43 NR 149. Brown, William M Etux Janie A RPUD 2005 VAIL RD 0.45 NR 150. Ellis, Stephen R Etux Sonya M RPUD 2009 VAIL RD 0.47 NR 151. Mahmud, Shahzad RPUD 801 BOULDER DR 0.35 NR 152. Shute, Deborah Ann RPUD 2001 ESTES PARK DR 0.39 NR 153. Sabhaya, Jaysukh Etux Jayshree RPUD 2000 CHEYENNE PARK LN 0.38 NR 154. Jorge Family Trust RPUD 704 BOULDER DR 0.51 NR 155. Estes Park Ltd RPUD 641 CASTLE ROCK DR 1.70 NR 156. Gordon, Eric C Etux Jane S RPUD 2101 DENVER DR 0.39 NR 157. Khan, Mohammed A Etux Hina H RPUD 649 BOULDER DR 0.35 NR 158. Carroll, Thomas Etux Elizabeth RPUD 2020 VAIL RD 0.37 NR 159. Koskovich, Charles Etux RPUD 2024 VAIL RD 0.48 NR 160. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1801 N WHITE CHAPEL BLVD 18.50 NR 161. Reedy, James R & Y Swearengin ECZ 501 MONTE CARLO DR 0.23 NR 162. Steinford, Sherri Ann ECZ 509 MONTE CARLO DR 0.25 NR 163. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1705 LE MANS LN 0.16 NR 164. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1701 LE MANS LN 0.16 NR 165. Brynmar Capital Llc ECZ 609 ORLEANS DR 0.21 NR 166. Sweeting, James Etux Karyn S ECZ 613 ORLEANS DR 0.24 0 Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 4 167. Houtman, Daniel J Etux Cristi ECZ 1717 RIVIERA LN 0.15 NR 168. Matousek, Timothy P ECZ 1713 RIVIERA LN 0.12 NR 169. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 1709 RIVIERA LN 0.12 NR 170. Clark, Robert K Etux Nancy ECZ 1701 RIVIERA LN 0.17 NR 171. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 1705 RIVIERA LN 0.12 NR 172. Ortiz, Louis M Etux Alison ECZ 400 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.15 NR 173. Mochulsky, Richard Etux Irene ECZ 402 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 174. Lassiter, Todd Etux Tracey ECZ 404 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 0 175. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 406 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 176. Heese, Karen Etvir J J Grech ECZ 408 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 177. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 410 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 178. Aybar, Raphael Etux Susan ECZ 412 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 179. K Hovnanian Home-Dfw Llc ECZ 414 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 180. Hovnanian Homes-Dfw Llc/ Paul Szablowski and Patti Larson ECZ 416 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 0 181. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 418 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 182. Marshall, Lawrence & Paula R ECZ 420 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 183. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 422 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.10 NR 184. Digiovanni, David A Etux L G ECZ 417 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 F 185. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 419 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 186. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 423 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.10 NR 187. Moreno, Guillermo H ECZ 421 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 188. Evans, Thomas & Kimberly ECZ 415 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 189. Ro, Yang Soo Etux Jeong H Lee ECZ 403 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 190. Bass, Mario J Etux Renee Bass ECZ 405 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 191. Schockett, Steven M & Lynda H ECZ 407 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 0 192. Benjamin, Carol A ECZ 409 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 193. K Hovnanian Homes-Dfw Llc ECZ 413 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 194. Brinkman, William & D Brinkman ECZ 411 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.13 NR 195. Bussell, Phillip Etux Laura ECZ 612 ORLEANS DR 0.26 NR 196. Townsend, Jay C & Faye ECZ 600 ORLEANS DR 0.30 NR 197. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1750 LE MANS LN 0.48 NR 198. Burch, Mike J ECZ 1633 RIVIERA LN 0.16 0 199. Southlake, City Of ECZ 400 E KIRKWOOD BLVD 4.91 NR 200. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 709 MONTE CARLO DR 0.39 NR 201. Haque, Atif Etux Nazia RPUD 2004 VAIL RD 0.34 NR 202. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 713 MONTE CARLO DR 0.34 NR 203. Hernandez, Victor Etux Francin RPUD 2008 VAIL RD 0.35 NR 204. Gitter, Kenneth H Etux Amy E RPUD 2016 VAIL RD 0.34 NR 205. Duhon, M Shawn Etux Christie RPUD 2012 VAIL RD 0.34 NR 206. Braich, Jaskanwal Etux Carolin ECZ 705 MONTE CARLO DR 0.42 NR 207. Bowman, Whitney R RPUD 2000 VAIL RD 0.50 NR 208. Soulier, Paul D Etux Mary E SF1-A 1005 CARROLL MEADOWS CT 1.07 NR 209. Jones, Steven W II Etux M ECZ 717 MONTE CARLO DR 0.38 NR 210. K Hovnanian Homes-Dfw Llc ECZ 1629 LE MANS LN 0.16 NR 211. K Hovnanian Homes-Dfw Llc ECZ 1625 LE MANS LN 0.15 NR 212. K Hovnanian Home-Dfw Llc ECZ 1621 LE MANS LN 0.14 NR 213. K Hovananian Homes-Dfw Llc ECZ 1617 LE MANS LN 0.14 NR Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 5 214. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 1613 LE MANS LN 0.14 NR 215. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 1609 LE MANS LN 0.13 NR 216. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1605 LE MANS LN 0.12 NR 217. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 1601 LE MANS LN 0.12 NR 218. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1533 LE MANS LN 0.12 NR 219. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1529 LE MANS LN 0.13 NR 220. Blaser, Brandon L RPUD 805 SILVERTON ST 0.37 NR 221. K Hovnanian Homes-Dfw Llc ECZ 1633 LE MANS LN 0.16 NR 222. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 420 ORLEANS DR 0.21 NR 223. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1751 LE MANS LN 0.20 NR 224. Kutch, John M & Helen F Kimble ECZ 505 MONTE CARLO DR 0.20 NR 225. Brensinger, Patrick Etux Kathr ECZ 300 ORLEANS DR 0.48 NR 226. Clayton, Douglas Etux Alicia ECZ 308 ORLEANS DR 0.22 NR 227. Holmes, John M Etux Jodi ECZ 404 ORLEANS DR 0.21 NR 228. Bantwala, Salman ECZ 408 ORLEANS DR 0.21 0 229. Fu, Jeffrey Etux Hilary ECZ 412 ORLEANS DR 0.21 NR 230. Elizondo, Rodolfo Etux Lidice ECZ 416 ORLEANS DR 0.21 0 231. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 424 ORLEANS DR 0.21 NR 232. Dixon, Michael ECZ 604 ORLEANS DR 0.23 NR 233. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 401 PALLADIAN BLVD 0.16 NR 234. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1681 LE MANS LN 0.91 NR 235. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 833 ORLEANS DR 0.07 NR 236. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 704 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 237. Keshireddy, Shanthanu ECZ 708 ORLEANS DR 0.19 0 238. Larson, Jacalyn E Etvir Dale L ECZ 712 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 239. Tian, Wei Etvir Eugene Shore ECZ 716 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 240. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 720 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 241. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 724 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 242. Wrenn, Scott Etux Hana Quach ECZ 800 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 243. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 618 ORLEANS DR 0.92 NR 244. Kandula, Kishore Etux Divyashr ECZ 705 ORLEANS DR 0.19 0 245. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 709 ORLEANS DR 0.18 NR 246. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 713 ORLEANS DR 0.18 NR 247. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 717 ORLEANS DR 0.18 NR 248. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 721 ORLEANS DR 0.18 NR 249. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 725 ORLEANS DR 0.18 NR 250. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1700 N CARROLL AVE 20.94 NR 251. Patel, Bhupendrakumar V ECZ 700 ORLEANS DR 0.21 NR 252. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 828 ORLEANS DR 0.60 NR 253. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 824 ORLEANS DR 0.26 NR 254. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 628 ORLEANS DR 0.51 NR 255. Bankhead, R Dale & Athena ECZ 624 ORLEANS DR 0.23 NR 256. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 816 ORLEANS DR 0.20 NR 257. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 812 ORLEANS DR 0.20 NR 258. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 808 ORLEANS DR 0.21 NR 259. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 804 ORLEANS DR 0.20 NR 260. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 829 ORLEANS DR 0.25 NR 261. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 801 ORLEANS DR 0.18 NR Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 6 262. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1525 LE MANS LN 0.12 NR 263. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1521 LE MANS LN 0.13 NR 264. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1517 LE MANS LN 0.13 NR 265. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1513 LE MANS LN 0.14 NR 266. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1509 LE MANS LN 0.18 NR 267. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1505 LE MANS LN 0.24 NR 268. Gross, Ken Paul Etux Betsy ECZ 625 ORLEANS DR 0.20 F 269. Agarwal, Manish Kumar ECZ 701 ORLEANS DR 0.22 NR 270. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 805 ORLEANS DR 0.18 NR 271. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 809 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 272. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 813 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 273. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 817 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 274. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 821 ORLEANS DR 0.19 NR 275. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 350 ORLEANS DR 0.83 NR 276. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 401 E KIRKWOOD BLVD 0.67 NR 277. Dixon, Lori Michelle ECZ 400 ORLEANS DR 0.22 0 278. Wilson, Bradley & Ashley ECZ 721 MONTE CARLO DR 0.65 NR 279. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 816 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.28 NR 280. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 812 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.27 NR 281. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 808 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.28 NR 282. K Hovnanian Homes - Dfw Llc ECZ 804 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.32 NR 283. Smith -Ware, Taniqua ECZ 800 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.30 NR 284. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 716 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.08 NR 285. Etheredge, Christoper & Elizab ECZ 712 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.30 NR 286. Briseno, Michael Etux Marissa ECZ 708 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.32 NR 287. Brynmar Capital Llc ECZ 709 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.31 NR 288. Starwood Custom Homes Llc ECZ 713 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.32 NR 289. Lele, Himalaya Etux Sharmila ECZ 701 MONTE CARLO DR 0.58 0 290. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 600 E KIRKWOOD BLVD 1.00 NR 291. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 704 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.58 NR 292. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 602 ORLEANS DR 0.25 NR 293. Monden, Jason ECZ 608 ORLEANS DR 0.21 NR 294. Rhima, Motaz A ECZ 700 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.79 NR 295. Thomas, Biju ECZ 705 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.51 NR 296. Children's Medical Center ECZ 470 E SH 114 9.80 NR 297. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1500 N CARROLL AVE 0.41 NR 298. K Hovnanian Homes Dfw Llc ECZ 801 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.35 NR 299. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 805 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.34 NR 300. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 809 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.32 NR 301. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 813 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.32 NR 302. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 817 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.32 NR 303. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 821 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.32 NR 304. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 825 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.32 NR 305. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 829 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.34 NR 306. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 837 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.37 NR 307. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 800 E KIRKWOOD BLVD 1.32 NR 308. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 833 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.35 NR 309. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 901 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.37 NR Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 7 310. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 905 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.35 NR 311. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 909 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.35 NR 312. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 913 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.35 NR 313. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 917 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.35 NR 314. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 921 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.35 NR 315. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 925 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.36 NR 316. Windsor Homes Cumberland Llc ECZ 924 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.38 NR 317. Windsor Homes Cumberland Llc ECZ 920 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.38 NR 318. Singhania, Anh N & Neil A ECZ 916 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.36 NR 319. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 908 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.34 NR 320. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 904 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.34 NR 321. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 900 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.33 NR 322. Gehan Homes Ltd ECZ 836 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.33 NR 323. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 820 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.31 NR 324. Gehan Homes Ltd ECZ 832 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.33 NR 325. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 828 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.30 NR 326. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1501 LE MANS LN 0.33 NR 327. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 629 ORLEANS DR 0.54 NR 328. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 825 ORLEANS DR 0.18 NR 329. Flexer, David J Etux Karen J R RPUD 917 SILVERTON ST 0.82 NR 330. Haque, Salima Etvir Mohammed RPUD 855 SILVERTON ST 0.46 NR 331. Steen, Michael & Maria ECZ 1808 CHEYENNE PARK LN 0.35 NR 332. Depperman, Chris ECZ 1804 CHEYENNE PARK LN 0.37 NR 333. Estrada, Roberto F Montemayor RPUD 851 SILVERTON ST 0.40 0 334. Flores, David & Luzinda Diaz ECZ 1812 CHEYENNE PARK LN 0.36 NR 335. Mitchangelo Investments Llc ECZ 920 GIVERNY LN 0.31 NR 336. Mitchangelo Investments Llc ECZ 916 GIVERNY LN 0.28 NR 337. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 812 PYRENEES DR 0.39 NR 338. Tresor Homes Llc ECZ 808 PYRENEES DR 0.37 NR 339. Jjco Inc ECZ 809 BURGUNDY LN 0.40 NR 340. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 804 PYRENEES DR 0.46 NR 341. Ford, Jeremy ECZ 813 PYRENEES DR 0.40 NR 342. Tran, Tung ECZ 809 PYRENEES DR 0.36 NR 343. R & R Residential Llc ECZ 801 PYRENEES DR 0.36 NR 344. Dixon, Michael ECZ 805 PYRENEES DR 0.36 NR 345. K Hovnanian Homes-Dfw Llc ECZ 917 GIVERNY LN 0.28 NR 346. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 901 GIVERNY LN 0.28 NR 347. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 905 GIVERNY LN 0.27 NR 348. McCollough, Vance & Karen Etal ECZ 805 BURGUNDY LN 0.35 NR 349. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 912 GIVERNY LN 0.43 NR 350. K Hovnanian Homes-Dfw Llc ECZ 909 GIVERNY LN 0.31 NR 351. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 913 GIVERNY LN 0.31 NR 352. Landolfo, A Peter Etux Deanna RPUD 913 SILVERTON ST 0.61 NR 353. Reinke, Martin H Etux Chian-H RPUD 909 SILVERTON ST 0.54 NR 354. Little, Steven J Etux Leigh D RPUD 905 SILVERTON ST 0.50 NR 355. Bartlett, John Brett RPUD 901 SILVERTON ST 0.45 NR 356. Starwood Custom Homes Llc ECZ 800 BURGUNDY LN 0.38 NR 357. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 804 BURGUNDY LN 0.36 NR Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 8 358. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 808 BURGUNDY LN 0.36 NR 359. Spiegel, Charles A & Claudia R ECZ 816 BURGUNDY LN 0.75 NR 360. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 812 BURGUNDY LN 0.36 NR 361. Meritage Homes Of Texas Llc ECZ 824 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.30 NR 362. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 801 GIVERNY LN 0.28 NR 363. Marthi, Raghunath & Jyotiremay ECZ 805 GIVERNY LN 0.27 O 364. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 809 GIVERNY LN 0.27 NR 365. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 813 GIVERNY LN 0.27 NR 366. Bg Fox Llc & Tresor Custom Horn ECZ 817 GIVERNY LN 0.27 NR 367. Chaisson, John P & Arianne ECZ 821 GIVERNY LN 0.30 NR 368. Tresor Homes Llc ECZ 825 GIVERNY LN 0.31 NR 369. Southlake, City Of ECZ 816 GIVERNY LN 8.20 NR 370. Asrani, Sumeet ECZ 1800 CHEYENNE PARK LN 0.39 NR 371. Starwood Custom Homes Llc ECZ 801 BURGUNDY LN 0.37 NR 372. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 800 PYRENEES DR 0.42 NR 373. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 921 GIVERNY LN 0.34 NR 374. Shivers Family Ptnrship Ltd AG 1900 N WHITE CHAPEL BLVD 39.54 NR 375. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1000 LA SALLE LN 0.27 NR 376. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1004 LA SALLE LN 0.30 NR 377. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1012 LA SALLE LN 0.30 NR 378. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1016 LA SALLE LN 0.30 NR 379. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1024 LA SALLE LN 0.30 NR 380. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1028 LA SALLE LN 0.28 NR 381. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1036 LA SALLE LN 0.28 NR 382. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1032 LA SALLE LN 0.27 NR 383. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1551 ROCHELLE DR 0.13 NR 384. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1001 LA SALLE LN 0.29 NR 385. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1037 LA SALLE LN 0.28 NR 386. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ LA SALLE LN 0.95 NR 387. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1033 LA SALLE LN 0.27 NR 388. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1032 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.45 NR 389. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1029 LA SALLE LN 0.27 NR 390. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1028 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.44 NR 391. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1025 LA SALLE LN 0.30 NR 392. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1024 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.44 NR 393. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1021 LA SALLE LN 0.33 NR 394. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1020 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.49 NR 395. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1017 LA SALLE LN 0.35 NR 396. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1016 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.57 NR 397. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1013 LA SALLE LN 0.35 NR 398. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1012 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.58 NR 399. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1009 LA SALLE LN 0.33 NR 400. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1008 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.52 NR 401. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1000 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.45 NR 402. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1005 LA SALLE LN 0.30 NR 403. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1004 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.44 NR 404. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 929 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.37 NR 405. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 933 LAKE CARILLON LN 0.45 NR Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 9 406. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 900 E KIRKWOOD BLVD 1.27 NR 407. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 16 22.77 NR 408. Southlake, City Of ECZ 480 E SH 114 7.51 NR 409. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 1600 N CARROLL AVE 37.84 NR 410. K Hovnanian Homes-Dfw Llc ECZ 829 GIVERNY LN 0.51 NR 411. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 827 GIVERNY LN 0.14 NR 412. Hines Southlake Land Lp ECZ 833 GIVERNY LN 0.39 NR F: In Favor O: Opposed To U: Undecided NR: No Response Notices Sent: Two Hundred -Twenty (220) Responses Received: Twenty-seven (27) In Favor: 4 Opposed: 23 Undecided: No Response: Case No. Attachment E ZA15-002 Page 10 Surrounding Property Owner Responses Notification Response Form ZA15-002 Meeting Date: January 22, 2015 at 6:30 PM Alford, Carl S & Marylee PO Box 92517 Southlake Tx 76092 Direct questions and mail responses to: City of Southlake Planning & Development Services Notification Response 1400 Main St; Ste 310 Southlake, TX 76092 Phone: (817)748-8621 Fax: (817)748-8077 PLEASE PROVIDE COMPLETED FORMS VIA MAIL, FAX OR HAND DELIVERY BEFORE THE START OF THE SCHEDULED PUBLIC HEARING. Being the owner(s) of the property so noted above, are hereby in favor of opposed to undecided about (circle or underline one) the proposed Zoning Change and Development Plan referenced above. 7ha.nk)rdj(2;-t>` of So14¢k14)cCj Space for comments regarding your position-b, , n i;�- 4_�- +,, 0, a�}cnt�oa o_llc usl,n� 4-k L r'+es,d e.4s t ),,4 o u>AtrS a q drior7LL9 i%e 11'Ar� al v0 rc e . ,cje bbLk _ 0Ln4 i nveste'd in a �eclopyn 12f with ii e_ay;renme,? to h must cvi cJian�r ns�- �Pa�f; ,�oll�l��n. r�r;,li(� �koo� � ,II ;,orfl,e,n? �)'We , Lv'( 4tm ronf0rn2 �h 0u_r0.urrr4't /'0yena✓f r e 5li,' I C�t O rl S Or- b t& de e.ls e L. )h p Signature: � � Date: 13Tan_)2013 Additional Signature: Printed Name(s): r Q , I �Y. P I �t2re � N(5 r Must be property owner(s) whose name(s) are printed at top. Otherwise contact the Planning D4 Date: J3Tan.Izo15 Lee ill �or� One form per property. Phone Number (optional).- r�)7) 2-2-q-1/22-2, P%asr 4k, i� �fe�< art Char��PS,�ha+ v�llc�(��sfr;cf Shofflr �i 5+r� c+ art not- a��ec�c0) cis Pfomrse®, Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 1 January 29, 2015 To the City of Southlake Planning and Zoning Commission 1400 Main Street, Suite 310 Southlake, TX 76092 Cc: the Carillon Board of Directors and the Carillon Architectural Control Authority Re: Public Hearing Notice ZA 15-002, the proposed zoning change and development plan for the Carillon residential district This letter is to express our opposition to "standing seam" metal roofs and to suggest different types of metal roofs more appropriate to "Chateau" style homes. When one thinks of a chateaux, one thinks of a castle, fortress, estate but not something modern or industrial looking or with an industrial looking roof. Our opinion of specifically "standing seam" metal roofs: they are more appropriate for industrial buildings, barns, boat houses, farm houses, and "contemporary" structures. Please see the attached examples. Our opinion of "metal" roofs: They may actually be more expensive and sustainable than composition, however, if not the right style, they wouldn't fit into the existing description of the Carillon development or with the existing homes already built in the development and as depicted in the artist drawings submitted to the City by the developers. Our suggestion for metal roofs that would be more cohesive to the development: Metal roofs are available in styles that match the existing roofs and existing architectural descriptions. Examples are ATAS Castle Top, simulated dimensional metal roof shingles to provide the look of traditional asphalt, and classic diamond patterned metal shingles. If metal roofs are to be allowed, please require a more detailed description of the allowed styles, colors and finishes, such as "dark brown", "matt", and "coated", with "no reflective qualities", to ensure the roof will blend in with Oe existing roofs and not be reflective. Please see the attached examples. Our opinion of "contemporary": We are delighted that the Architectural Control Authority was asked to remove the word "contemporary" from the proposal. We also would disagree with any descriptions or wording changes that would still allow the "contemporary" or modernistic styles that do not fit into the current environment. We prefer to keep the descriptions of the facades and architectural designs as are currently written in the Carillon Zoning Booklet to ensure the continued cohesiveness of the development. If someone is allowed to build other than what we have, someone else would then have an argument to change the zoning again to allow a dome home, log home, modernists, bungalow, colonial cape cods, etc. How this affects us: We purchased our lot and built in Carillon because we loved the style of homes being built. We reviewed the developers' documents at the City of Southlake and loved the existing plans for the development, architectural descriptions of the homes, planned shopping, lake, parks, trails, and the artist renderings of all of these things. We've made a huge investment in our home in Carillon believing that we can live here well into our elder years because of the walkability, the accessibility of shopping in the future without a car, the close proximity to Forest Park Medical Center, and most importantly, we believed with all of our hearts that the City of Southlake would protect us and ensure that Carillon will be developed as written by the developers and approved by the City Planning and Zoning Commission. We had the same faith in the Carillon Architectural Control Authority. Don't open Pandora's Box: Please do not change our beautiful development, where many homes have already been built or committed to, for the desire of a builder or 1-3 potential home owners. Y.U. t3ox yLSl/ 1812 St. Philip Ave Southlake, TX 76092-0517 (817)980-5028 (817)229-4722 Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 2 Appropriate Metal Roofs for Classically Designed and "Chateau" Style Homes Metal Shingles & Metal Slate -�. -- Designed to give the great appearance of architectural shingles and rough hewn slate roofing, these are actually long-lasting steel - shingles - View Metal Shingles I Metal Slate >>> c wa'R k� I Examples metal roofs Metal Tile Roofing �a These provide the authentic look of +� i Spanish barrel clay tile. with the I ; ;\ air longevity. strength and wind resistance of 26 gauge AR00fin _View Metal Tile• � - � -% Fm ZA Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 3 0 "Standing Seam" metal roofs Standing seam metal roofs look appropriate for industrial use, barns, boat houses, log homes, farm houses and very contemporary homes. I do not believe they are appropriate for the classic architecture currently found in Carillon or as depicted in the artist renderings of what the developers submitted to the City of Southlake. k T Before building in Carillon I went to the City of Southlake and asked to see what the developers were planning. This is a photo from the booklet submitted by the developers depicting their vision of the Chateau District. I see "Chateaux" style homes. Although there are many classic styles, I see no industrial looking homes, farm houses, or homes that are modernistic or contemporary in appearance. I certainly don't visualize "standing seam" roofs. Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 4 24.`0�5 0 skixhl-Ae:x -is Ma I -Re: 7'% 15-CC2 - Car.11or map V Mo Planning&Zcr ng Commission- update needed 19{ v r 5OUTHILAKE Holly Blake [hblake@cLsouthlake.tx.us> Re. ZA 15-002 - Carillon map for the Planning $ Zoning Commission - update needed 1 message MaryLee Alford Tue, Feb 3. 2015 at 6:67 PM Reply -To: MaryLee Air❑rd -iF To - "nblake@ci.south lake. ix- us" {hbiake@ci.soui•nane.tx.us>, Jeff Kennemer <jeff.kennemerOhines.corn> Hello, My husbanc and I attended the last P&Z meetirg regarding ZA 15-002 During the meeting Je`r Kunnemer was askod how many lots have been sold and built upon ar.d, he didirl know. The attached map shows the answer to that question as of August 13: 2014. Carillon does keep track a� that data and he should he able to give an up-to-date answer by the February 5th meeting. Best regards, q r p P. 0. Box 92517 1812 St. Philip Ave. Sauthlake, TX 76092 Map -Carillon lots sold -August 13, 2014.jpg 899K Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 5 Notification Response Form ZA15.002 Meeting Data: Jan€mar 22, 2015 at 0:30 RA AvIrneni, SAMba-siva Etux Ue-ha 308 Soulder Dr Southieke TY, 76092 PLEASE PROVIDE COMPLETED FORMS IVrIA MAIL, FAA OR HAND DELI €RY 1315POR� THE START O THE SCHEDULE-0 PUBLIC H€ARING. Being the owner(s) of the pr€aperty so doted aloe, are here — -_ -- �i:!�aavor apposed to undecided about (circle or underline one) the proposed Zoning Change and Develop—ment Plan referenced above. SWO for commonts regarding your position: Signature: Additional Signature: Printed Narne(s): Must be property owner(a) whass9 narna(a) are Phone Number (optinonal)- at Date. 3 Date: ing Department. One form per property. Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 6 'Y VV1 Notification Response Form ZA15-002 M60ting GVte: i3nuary 2", 2015 at 5- 0 P v? S+chockeft, orntwen M & Lynda H 407 Palladian Blvd Sauthlake Tx 76092 PLEASE P OWD4- COMPLETED FORMS VPA MAIL, FAX OR HAtw DELIVERY BEFORE THE START OF THE SOMEDULED PUMUC HEARia�G. Being the owner(s) of the property so raged above, are here -by in favor of apposed t4 undecided about (circle or underline arse) the proposed Zoning Change and Development Plan referenced above. Space for comments regarding your position: Signature. Date: 14& Additional Signatere�_ l ,fit-�� Date; i f !� Printed Neme(s): Must be property owner(s) whose name(s) are printed at top, otherwise—ntaK the Planning Department. One form per properly, Phone Number (optional): Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 7 Notification Response Form 7-A1 s-oa2 Mosting Date, January 22, 2015 at 6:30 PIM Marthi, Raghunaffb & Jyogramay 10215 M. trahant a h livings 4v 76003 PLEASE PROVIDE COMPLETED FORMS VIA MAIL, FAX OR HAND DELIVERY BEFORE THE START OF THE CHED LEO PUBLIC HEARING, Being the owner(e) of the property so noted above, are hereby in favor of opposed to undecided about (circle or underline one) the proposed Zoning Change and Development Plan refOrenced above. Space for comments regarding your poaiVon- Signature: r n Additional Signature: Date: 6- Date: l 0013� Printed Narne(s): _ ,1�� f' `��nA�, Q Must be property owner(s) whose name(3) are printed at top. Olherwlse contact the Planning One form per voparty, Phone Number (optional): 7q_ - - Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 8 Notification Response Form ZA15-002 Meeting Date: January 22, 2015 at 6:30 PM Claudio Moreno Revocable Trust 406 Saint Tropez Dr Southlake Tx 76092 PLEASE PROVIDE COMPLETED FORMS VIA MAIL, FAX OR HAND DELIVERY BEFORE THE START OF THE SCHEDULED PUBLIC HEARING. Being the owner(s) of the property so noted above, are hereby in favor of C-29—P-70 *:to undecided about (circle or underline one) the proposed Zoning Change and Development Plan referenced above. Space for comments regarding your position: Mo �(.Q )i� Cam% 0 �frIs c4CVA ca c ✓► uJ�� &(Jt'/tA t'LQA-Q iJ(J� �C1. ., '1 Li�P if�i (.cc�+ r:il{Uc lJ �C�t,at c�L ZrI� i ucti cot j vt ul�-e,4 yGA <Ot y a c4ev�r_W S �/� j n Signature: Date:( Additional Signature:— Date: /� 2qS ` Printed Name(s): Must be property owner(s) whose name(s) are printed at top. Otherwise contact the Planning Department. One form per property. Phone Number (optional): 6Q, C'7O aGCO Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 9 Notification Response Form ZA16-002 Meeting Date: January 22, 2015 at 6:30 PM Estrada, Roberto F Montemayor 851 Silverton St Southlake Tx 76092 PLEASE PROVIDE COMPLETED FORMS VIA MAIL, FAX OR HAND DELIVERY BEFORE THE START OF THE SCHEDULED PUBLIC HEARING. Being the owner(s) of the property so noted above, are hereby in favor of EpposedDto undecided about (circle or underline one) the proposed Zoning Change and Development Plan referenced above. Space for comments regarding your position: Signature: Additional Signature: Printed Name(s): W�-A Must be property owner(s) whose n me(s) are printed at top. Phone Number (optional): JPN 22 2015 p1,5:0 Date: rr Date: contact the Planning Npartment. One form per property. Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 10 From: Solomon's Furndure Fax: (880) 514.0191 To fax *1 (817) 748-8077 y, p� Page 1 of 1_ D1l22l2015 2,55 i on OW � J:s. w![� ..� •w z`•` _':^: ` tZ,_ WO ME R ��;� z y'�"•� l - � .h T � '�41� M0-4 is i 4 , - �,� z xax 5iae3i3a '� ��` si �•��'t2- t 3; �� , \'� ��. �'�. K v � rev Y * �. t :. .-... -- _:. ...'. _...:. :,,..:' -•,. ter_. .. ...,a._:3sa;. ,x.. - ...+..-.:r., , l s i a s t + f1Et apeirt a. t Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 11 24=15 CI.Sa.lhielae,ixu5 MAi - PUBLIC HF_MINC, NOTICE ZA 15 a52, m r.r 4pmed xdning oange mid dvekipmsa plan fpr Ow C¢r'111an if"demi A rkirlol 13SOUTHILAU Holly Slaka <hblake@d,15outh1ake,lx.us> PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE ZA 15-002, the proposed zoning change and development plan for the C arilIon residen Eat district 1 meuaiogr: Melarie Roger Reply-Tc; Melelne Roger To: "hblake ci_rDLthl9k,.tc.us" <hblaKQ9C1,S0Ukn1aKe.tx.uS> Wed, Feb 4, 2015 at 12:52 PM As a resident of Carillon at IBM Riviera Lane, I would like to voice my apposition to the proposed zoning change to Include metal roofs_ We invested in building in this neighborhood wikb the under'standir:g that onlythe French style architecWre would be permitted. I trelieve the new styles would not ftt in with the overall look of the Carib development, I am pleased that the Arch KeoWral Control Authority was asked to remove the*ord "contemporary" from the proposal_ I also wouid oppose any descriptions or wDrding changes that would stil allow the "contemporary" or modernistic styles that do not fit into tbe, current environment. I prefer to keep the descriptions of the facades and architectural designs as are currently written In the Carillon Zoning Booklet to ensure the continued cohesiveness of the development. Please do not change our beautiful development, where many homes have already been built or committed to, fur the desire of a builder or 1-3 potential home owners. Thank you for helping project our neighborhood and investment in Southiake_ Jacqueline GLdhrie 1833 Riviera Lane Southlake TX 76092 817-23-5588 hklps�rnia�l, gpo�e�rnrm aLti►Nlrrli=d6ika8�'5d8V Idr�.Pl&sew'eM.Ir�ax81h=14�&SeRk51t3e�38s Im1=141f1.+�9� Case No. ZA15-002 91 Attachment F Page 12 Notification Response Form ZAI S-002 Meeting Date: January_ 22, 2oi s at 6:3o PM Lele, Himalaya Etux Sharmila 701 Monte Carlo Dr 5authlake Tx 7W92 Dinbet quesdom and umil resporrms W: City of soutillake Plarining & DevekWww Ivt Servwe$ i lotifw--at on Respcwtse 1400 Main St; Sae 310 souttrla ke, TX ism Pttone: (8171748-SW Fa:_ (817)746-SM PLEASE PROVIDE COMPLETED FORMS VIA MAIL., FAX OR HAND DEUVERY BEFORE THE START OF THE SCHEDULED PUBLIC HEARING. Being the owner(s) of the Property so noted above. are hereby in favor of (opposed to) undecided about (circle or underline ore) the Proposed Zoning Change and Development Plan referenced above. Space for comments regarding your position: t C, { ? 1 111111: r'ir1 1 IC ou--- Signature: Additional Signature: Printed Name(s): `It,n q Must be properly orals) �Awse name(sj are printed top Phone Number (optional): Scanned by CarnScanner Date: �� ! Date: i o the Gm fwm per pwpe,ti,. Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 13 Moir, Q.suutHake.d..usIAed-DDHIOW90thewOrgtypesInCarllrcn!I 19 ,SOUMILAI E Holly Make chb1ake@cl.s0i1thlak@.bc.ua> Don't change the roofing types in Carillanll t rn-esszge Hlma To: hblake[gui.southlake.tx,us Tue. Feb 3, 2015 at 3:11 PM Hello, my nania is Fimalaya Itele, l live at 701 Monte Carlo drive in the Qjrillon suNivision, my phone number is 817-480-4774, II am OPPOSED to the new zoning change allooing standing seam metal roots. I don't want theta to be any new types of ro&n allowed in Carl Ilan. Just What is aumntl[y allowed. I feel that davelopem often do this type of 'bait and swilch' tactics, starting a development with high standards and then lowering Therm so they can sell houses faster and stlll charge a premium to the unsuapeating public, This Icnwm pmparty values of the peogle who have alm.,My moved In to a neighborhood and Is urdeir to them. Please stop the standing seam metal roofs. It will look unattraot ive and make $cu;hlake lock Very c kia-cutbw, somethN that so for we as a city have resist$d unlike many other cites In the DFW area, Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 14 Jan 21 2015 5:13PM K. Sutherland (8173 416-2123 page 1 Notification Response Form ZA7 "02 Meeting Date: January 22, 201; at 9:30 PRQ Sutherland, Kapneth Etux K 1809 Saint Philip Ave Southlake Tx 76092 PLEASE PROVi®E COMPLETED FORMS VIA MAIL, FAX OR HAND DELI y ERY BEFORE THE START OF THE SCHEDULED PUBLIC HEARING, - _ - Being -the owner(6) of the property so not i-a%®ve, in favor of opposed fib undecided about (circle or unde►iine one) the proposed Zoning Change and Development Plan referenced above. Space for comments. regardiing your pose lon: Signatu e Date: S Additional Signature: Date: 1 rsf Printed Name(a Must be property owner(s) whtose nor► s tact at to Q9henaise contact the Piannin 'Da rtme . n rm r P� p g P® Q e fp p® properly. Phone Number (optional): Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 15 Notification Response Form ZA15-002 Meeting Date: January 22, 2015 at 6:30 PM Steen, Michael Etux Maria 421 Monte Carlo Dr Southlake Tx 76092 Direct questions and mail responses to: City of Southlake Planning & Development Services Notification Response 1400 Main St; Ste 310 Southlake, TX 76092 Phone: (817)748-8621 Fax: (817)748-8077 PLEASE PROVIDE COMPLETED FORMS VIA MAIL, FAX OR HAND DELIVERY BEFORE THE START OF THE SCHEDULED PUBLIC HEARING. Being the owner(s) of the property so noted above, are hereby in favor of opposed to undecided about (circle or underline one) the proposed Zoning Change and Development Plan referenced above. Space for comments regarding your position: Signature: Additional Signature: Date: 0' / Date: 0' / 1- I S Printed Narne(s): MAeva 1�k "IcHAEt sTr=� Must be property owner(s) whose name(s) are printed at top. Otherwise contact the Planning Department. One form per property. Phone Number (optional): Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 16 USOUTHLAKE Holly Blake <hblake@ci.southlake.tx.us> Zoning change 2 messages Tracey Lassiter Mon, Jan 26, 2015 at 4:34 PM To: "hblake@ci.southlake.tx.us" <hblake@ci.southlake.tx.us> My husband Todd Lassiter and myself, Tracey Lassiter live at 404 Palladian Blvd, Southlake, 76092. We are against the metal roofing proposed change. We think it would change the look and feel of the original plan, Thank you, Todd and Tracey Lassiter 817-239-8611 Sent from my iPhone Holly Blake <hblake ci.southlake.tx.us> Mon, Jan 26, 2015 at 4:51 PM To: Tracey Lassiter Thank you Tracey t wilt make qi ira tha r:nmmission gets a copy of your email [Quoted text hidden] Holly Blake Administrative Secretary - Planning Certified Permit Technician - Building Inspections City of Southlake 817-748-8621 hblake@ci.southiake. tx. us Of CSOUTHLA.E Standing Seam Metal Roofs 1 message 1111"ne Neal To: hblake@cl.southlake,tx.us Cc. Dwayne Neal - Hally Blake <hblake@d.&outhlake.tx.us.> Wed, Feb d, 201:5 at 3:11 PM Dear SirlMadam, My name N Dwayne Neel, My wife and I live at 1817 St. Phl lip Ave_ In the Carillon Addition 131 Southlake. In discussions wilt", some of my neighbors I have learned that there is a proposed zoning change to the development that: would allow -standing seam metal roots. ] along wMlh many -of my other neighbors, we are strongiV against this 7onin9 change_ Beyond not being in good taste and style with the rest of the nelghborhood, it would quite ptassibly aPp. cl the value of existing homes in bath the Estates and the Chsteau districts of the addition. Thank you very much for taking into consideration our Feelings as you make your decision on this unneGasssry zoning change_ Respectfully yours, Dwayne Neal Dana Neal Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 17 1/26/2015 Ci.southlake.tx.us Mail - PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE ZA 15-002 SOUTHLAKE Holly Blake <hblake@ci.southlake.tx.us> PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE ZA 15-002 2 messages Maria Helena Arizaga de Moreno Mon, Jan 26, 2015 at 3:50 PM To: "hblake@ci.south lake.tx.us" <hblake@ci.southlake.tx.us> Hello My name is Maria Helena Moreno, my husband Claudio Moreno and I reside at 405 St. Tropez drive in Southlake. Our home tlf # is 7869990417 and my cell is 6126700600. I am sending this email in regards to the request to change the construction plans for my neighborhood CARILLON. I would like to ask the Planning and Zoning commission to please listen to us and not allow these changes to take place. The homeowners who currently live here bought into Carillon under the firm commitment that the design, feel and look would be consistent. The need of a few potential new owners cannot outweigh the original vision of our neighborhood. We believe allowing this could set future problems as to what type of homes can be built and would be totally out of line with the overall look that we are hoping to maintain. Trusting our petition will be heard, I thank you for your time Maria Helena Moreno Holly Blake <hblake@ci.south lake.tx.us> Mon, Jan 26, 2015 at 3:52 PM To: Maria Helena Arizaga de Moreno I have received your message and will make sure the Commission receives a copy. Keep my email and feel free to contact me anytime. [Quoted text hidden] Holly Blake Administrative Secretary - Planning Certified Permit Technician - Building Inspections City of Southlake 817-748-8621 hblake@ci.southlake. tx. us Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 18 21312615 Ci.soUthlake.ix.us Mail - Public Hearing Notif cation lloning Change/ZA 15-002 13f I I Y O SOUTHLAK:E Holly Blake thblake@ci.southlakeAx.us> Public Hearing Notification /Zoning Change/ ZA 15-002 1 message Ericka McCaw Tue, Feb 3, 2015 at 2:37 PM To: hb1ake9Ci.sourntake.tx.us Dear Planning and Zoning Commission, i am a resident of Carillon and just learned of the proposed Zoning change in our development which would allow for "standing seam" metal roofs. I actually had to read and reread the proposed changes as I was shocked to learn of this proposal. My husband and I moved to Southlake a little over a year age from North Carolina and we specifically selected Southlake for its attention to community planning and what this does for both improving and protecting property values. I'm appalled that these metal roofs would be even be considered as aesthetically acceptable. Carillon is developing into a Iovefy community and it is my feeling that allowing these metal roofs would dramatically decrease the neighborhood's desirability. I can be reached at the following address and phone: Ericka McCaw 1617 Riviera Lane Southlake TX 76092 Phone: 919.741.8389 Sincerely, Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 19 2WN15 C44V ftftU.n h11O1- PWbk NGBl QWO Z4 JnQ zA 7s W7 19urY oa SOLrrFLA,[<.EHolly Blake �hblake ci.southlake.tx,us> Public Hearing Notification 1Znninq Change/ ZA 15-00 t mess&�e Nell MaCa>. Wed, F*b 4, 2016 at 11:11 AM 7o: "hblake cLaouthiake.tx.us' <hblAe@oi.soutNake.tx.us> Planning and Zoning Commission, am a resident of Carillon. I was jibst made aware of the propcsed zoring change in our development which would allow b, "standing seam' tmlelal roofs. My wife and I specifically selected Southlake for Its attention Jo communitfr plenrfing and what that does for both Improving and proteoUng property values. I assume this is a bulMer or current home owner looking to Impose Ov it style Into the neighborhood. Please reject this proposal_ can he readied at the folloWN address and pborle; Nei McCaw 1617 Riviera Lane 5vuihlake TX 76092 Phone; 919.673,7949 FWspectfully. Neil McCaw r.:�s.„ rd �c��lectm+rnsilh.v➢''f�.i=28�k=eo737�fi25=Svier►�=PGS�rclv■�rda�Em■i��iml■14� Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 20 ZOOM U.*n i@ketx.Le Mall - PUBLIC HFAFtlNGNC rICE?-Ai -dM 13(-,rr,e Or 50UTHLAKE Holly Blake 4hb1ake Cl.aouthlake.b9-U5> PUBLIC HEARING MOTME ZA 15.002 n•.epsage Wed, Feb 4, 2015 at 12:33 PM io: hll�lake{�ci.€outhlaKe.Ix.us HeNo, I am resident in calimon community at 705 Orleans give and I appose to the Change Thanks Kish%a KandtAa 705 Orleans Dmre Coil - 312-404.7252 214n)15 0.aouWBke.tK.u. Mail - F'tb iv hoe-;M rrlice Z4615-002 10 c I v (7r C)Lf HLAV,E Holly Blake <hWiRke( ci.svut1hlakeAX,Ua> Public hearing notice A15-002 1 message Glmall To: *hb1ak9@6.9outhlake.tx.us" Oblake(oei,soukhlake.ix.us> I oppose this change. Sh;anthanu Keshireddy 708 Orleans dr, SWhlake, TX 76D92 Cell: 317-5264218 Sent frurr) my (Phone V%d, Feb 4, 2015 at 12 14 IIM Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 21 i Cn.SpuRl "-lX ae RUI - PUKX HEARM NM10E Lk 15-OM GIFY or SOL714LAI PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE Z.A 15-002 1 message Holly Blake ehblake@oi,xouthlakeAx,uis] Lldlefta Peuua Tus, Feb 3, 200 at 1027 AM To; "hblake i.sou%niake.lx.us" <hblake ci-southlake-tx,us* Hello My name is Lidice Pousa, my husband Claudfaa Elizondo and I reside at 416 Orleans Or in Carilw neigtkl pwhood, Southlake I am sending this~ wail in regardls to the request to change the eenOructIco plans for my neighbodwood CARILLON. 1 vmufd Il ke to ask the Planning and Zoning commission to pease listen to us and not allow these ohengea to take place. The homeowners who currently live here bought into Cariflon under the tirm commitment that the designr reel and look would be consigtgrC The need of a few potential new aumarrt Carraol oulweigh the original vision of our neighborhood, e bdliove allowing this could set future problems as to wf* type of homes ran be bultt and world be tutally out cf line with the overall look that we are hoping to maintain. Trusting our petltlorr will be heard. I thank you for your time Lidice PGusa Sent from my Phone 24=5 C1.6ouftAu.t« Mail - Zoning chanWfur Callron L415-OG2 Icrry tar SCUFMAKE Holly Blake <hbIake&1.s uthlake,tx.urs- Zoning change for Carillon ZA 15-002 1 message ,lam le Courtrw r Tue, Feb 3, 2015 at 7.00 PM To. "hblakeli.,,x '..:,v,s,Uo-+w,eI,soulhlelce,tx,Us> My nernc is Jamie Courtney apd I Ilve at 401 Monte Carlo Dr. In the Carillon neighborhood. I would like to express my desire to NOT allow the zoning change to allow "standinq sears" metal roofs in the Estates and or Chateaus District* of Carillon, If you riwd to talk to me, I can be reached at 317-679-2666. Thank y%, Jamie Courtney Sent from my Wad Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 22 2rsr2015 Cisajlhl".bu9WIN- Conlon ReWrdngRa4reawdZ ningCtnngefo•carll anLA'frh7! (' rrv' fl- SOUTHLAKE Holly Blake <hblake0l,S0uthlak,e.ix.u5> Opinion Regarding Requested Zoning Change for Carillon ZA 15-00 1 lases sage Susan Beno" Tua, Feb a, 2015 al 7M FM To: hblakiQri.5outhlake.tx_us - - Cc; Roben Banoli -` ' ' As residervis of Carillon both my husband am I are opposed to allowing standing seam metal roofs In the Estates and Chateau Dlsldets. We bel leve this request is W in keeping with the original French F enainarica Inspired development theme that was approved. We bellave that standing seam metal rndfs are more corn merolal and industrial in nature. We also balieve from an architectural stand point a standing &earn metal roof more arChltecturally filling for a Texas hill country. Sincerely, Susan M Benoit Robert F Benoit 1813 Riviura Lane Southlake, TX 76092 682. 597.M3 CARILLON Block: 20 Lot; 9R 24=6 CI.9DAhl&ke.bU8 Mall • CBrllkm P -ZL Z lwlly Blake q�{pkygrl�rilhlelce.u.re�r Carillon P A I t eF9a9; 94 PWfE 8 LOMELA neolnVANN ref-T4 r.'.;VF 8 .QrbkDA Ell r RK 1Prt15ket'(d.!0u111mke'—o' _...nwcylrtk 66Nhnke.[[.us} NI. H&va bmd rviv it Idr)Rlasbe ftwAn BRar si8rd&r Iha procae In 2019. Wa lave i heraasweFzme barn hn SL'VIhbh9 ebrta 2061 And wtriNdIn 919y 99 our iinitr# qulebly4tli9 heroae. I heveNOprebW wM the alan&g aearrttwit In d7e Eelale4andChai"u Dirt e. I be1145vy ne ruu+sviN aW aqualkywu+tl0wadb*F mane and wml9 ahm affM anVy fnOtlefty skyW hareem rn any C the dlalfela (please gee II-9 eyewe They bjRla Ve Co-erdry Nelphhtel'OW on Tumbwq Ln wd Wnvkh -Ct). I t pool. p9rha 90 9rA9r+araand a onoProbr4mv,lthilre roaig praWedd Thank y+we hpr ywwr *r Ovaq 0J4knwnry 4iF Pamodlan AW 8i7.945.2 O9 Daur DGC 3yanry Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 23 2FAM16 . 2DON IIN4 C R NGE Z4-1M SCK � HIE Holly Koke chb1ake@Ci.southIake.tx,us> ZON HN G CHANCE ZA-15002 1 message Patti Larsor To: hblake ,.,-sounnlake.tx,us To whom this may concem. VVED are hone owners in the Carillon Developmerrt In Southlake_ Paul Szablowskl Paip Larson 416 Palladiian Blvd Southlake T 430-250,2905 Wed. Feb 4, 2015 at 10_29 AM VV8 understand that we have a right, as hormowners in the development, to express our opinion reg80N the proposed zoning notloe for consideration of "Standing ~seam Metal Roofs' We would be appoued to allowing this type roof material - Thanks for your considarabon- Patti Larson 2W21)15 Ci-adJll'iacP1x.us Mall - Frcpotml rMCt IIft -or 4.9rmcA 135MTHLAI,f,E I HipIIy Slake <hblake@ci,southlake.tx-us> Proposed roof changes for Carillon 1 message Kasw" Sweetlin& To.. "hblake ci.86uthIake,lx,us" <hWake ci_sou1f11ar I3AX.Us> Planning and Zoning Wed, Feb 4, 2015 at 2-52 PM I am unable to attencll tornorrmVs meeting tart I would like 10 express my concerns regarding the metal roof Proposal. I am egalrist changing the currant z-onlrrg mstrictiom that would alkw a metal roof. I feel it would change the Integrity of the current Fremh rogfing styles chat are currently In the neighborhood_ Thank you, Karyn end Jim 5weeting 613 Odleane drive SMhlake Texas. 78092 Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 24 y5rM15 Q1-w J Ak0XK.U$Maul-Zgryng-roarrsllmMwore 19GrrY C+r SOMT-1"KE Holly Blake -�hblake Lsouthlake.tc.uox Zoning Carrillon meeting 1 message Lori Dhwn _ Thu, Fob 5, 2015 9 2142 PM Ta 'hblake&I.,%uuLh1ake_tx_us' -Chblak ci.routhlake.tx.uv To whom it may cowerre I am not able to make today's meeting. However I would like 10 express my opposltian of the zoning change that vhould allow standing seam m0al roofs In the cartlbn development. I am a resident of the c.anllon -develwmanl at 400 Orleans Dr., Southlake-, TX 76052_ While then a types of roof materials may he axpens ive, I -do not feel Mal they fit In wlth the development as intended. I have scan 1hesa types of roof rriaterials used in corn mercial deu$Iopment and otl*r types of areas and I am not a tan of how they look. So please take this email M my vole in oppDsiliorl or ibis change. Thank you! Lad Dixon 2QW1S 19Crry Cn SCUTHLAKE "NO STANDING SEAM " 1 message C1.90a>raxe.0 ug Mall - 110 STANIDII iG SE . Holly 13l$ka <hInlakeeci.southliLke.tx.us5 cMa banatuvaia T v Thu, Feb 5, 2015 et 1 1=40 AM To; hblakeQcl,sOUthIAka_tx.us I am a resident or Carilion living on 408 01sa-is Dr and i nppuFe the nropusltion of having standing seam metal roots . C,yma Banatwala3 a1776W762 Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 25 3+42015 G r iJ'19SOLI[� qq r 1L 3 E Zoning proposal - Carillon t message (dike J. Burch - .. To; hblake@oi.-30u1nlake-tx-u51 Dear Zoning and Planning Cammissloner. Ci,aoutHEkabija Mall-2AdrgpropceEr - CEnllar Holly Blaka <hbIake ci.southlaku.tx,us> Wei Feb 4, 2015 at 2:30 PM I am writing to you with concern over the proposed zoning change In our development for the allowance of standing seem' metal rooilrig. Speclfrcelly, pnpmed zoning change amendment iA-1504Z. As a Southlake resident arrd community voluntear, l chose to live in Carillon for the developer and builders master plan erld architectural plans. The vintage appeal and adds to the general neighborhood $nvlronment and helps protect our Investment. Metal roots gerreralty are constructed on uber conseivetive homes and lower rent warehousing feollities, In Short, It contradicts the corrstltution of the Carillon brand. I am hopeful that corrsideraticn to theamendmem to not Include these metal raafa as stricken iri a decisive manner. Proponerrts of such obluse m8tar:513 to roof their horna. will most likely have other changes in mind that compr Mi96 M clears and crisp aesthetic of the homes in the Villas and Estates of Carillon. Thank you very much. Sincerely, Mike J. Burch 214--980-8300 Cad[kn reskkW since Owober 2013 Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 26 Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 27 26 013 [%mgNeke,KusMaI-PUBLICHEARINGNOTICEZA115-= ICFTY nF SOUTFLAKE Molly 9Jake -chblake ci.Southlake.tx.us> PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE ZA 15-d002 1 messace Thu, Feb 5, 2015 at 10:01 AM To; hblakeQcl,scuthlaKe.tx,us To tha gmehlaka P&Z RE'. Public Hearina Notice FA 15-002 - Standinu Seam Metal Roofs in Chateau QIMZ in pad Ilan To begin, I would like to sincerely thank every member of the P&Z for your dedicated off aits in making 9outhlake whm It Is today. We love Southlake and all that it offers I Regarding CM10A and stand-ing seem metal rods, we chose this development because of the beauty of aach district, the open spaces, and the unique architectue, VVe believe the developer ha6 done an outstan 5fig job in developing the community and will continue to do so_ Only in Carillon can Vou f}nd a community where the developer has been alhle to blend large natlonal builders and small buiIders to create a truly beautiful and unique cpmmxdty. They should be commended, and we are happy they any h�rc, not to mention the newly finished lake an„beautiful. Equally important to us is the d yvelapers&E-rm right to control the development In a manner that best serves the rommundy and protecting the overall value of our Investment. This should Include approval of metal roofs, provided the home ftelf, fits into the commu"ty. In fact, it's really not about the roof nv tWal, it`s about the home style. And, I think this is when all of us as homeowners (even those oMeuting to metal roofs) are on the same page. The proverbial saying "don't throw the baby out with the bathwater applies here. You cannot auturmlivally equate a metal roof to a Bam. Ultra Moderrti, a Frew Mansard roof, or a Country French home,__.., each of which could havo a metal rrd to compriment Its style_ Belopx is an a-rnall from Dr. David 1010c vanni who lives in a Villa on Palladian and is also supportive of metal roofs; but against any type of home that does not fit into the community, Dr. Digiovannt references a home In the subdivision of Coventry on the corner of Tumberry Ln. and Norwhich Ct_ that is ultra modem; and I thInk all a6 us would sgree; It Is nbt smathl hg we want in Carillon_ I have attached a picture of this harne and of a home in Vaquero that also has a metal roof. The Va,gUwo hones style is beautiful and would surely fit very well into the Chateau DIstrlct. So It's not about the roof. It's about the home. Please "don't throw the baby out with the bathwaterl" Approve standing seam metal roofs and cvntinue to allow the ACA to develop OariilIon m they have in the past, with beautiful b mes and distinct architecture that creates the true beauty of Carillon. Thank you for listening and giving consideration to the real issue at hand. We are all neighbors and I think we all went the same thing; be"ful homes that allow for individual creativRy 1A+i#hin a coft'died development. Sinneyply, Ken & Betsy Cross 625 Orleans Dr, 817-791-1114 Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 28 '15M15 Ci.9whekeLix.usM84-FW41PUBLIC HEARING NOME7AIS-= tNpmp]madFu:iimi::h ngeand dffalcpmeMplanfor QVr.O IlcnrggdeMel46biot 19CxVY OF SOUTHLAKE Holly Make 9:h41ake cl.soLlthlak$_tx.ues Fw d: PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE ZA 15-002, the proposed zoning change and development plan for the Carillon residential district 1 message Ryan Rage. To: 'hblake@si.saathlake_lx.us" xhbloke ci.southl-ake.tx_us> Wedt Feb 4. 2015 at 4:43 PM As a resident of CariJlan at 1633 Riviera Lane, I would like to voice my opposition to the proposed zoning change to Inckide metal roofs. We Invested in building In this neighborhood with the understanding that only the French style archiWlure would be permitted. I belleve the new styles would not Fit in with the overall Cook of the CarlIlDn dev*pmerlt. I am pleased that the Architectural Control Awthorltywas asked to remove the ward'contempporary" frorn the proposal. I also would appose 0.ny descnptims or wording changes that would stlll allow the "contemporary" or modernistic styles that do not fit inta the current environment. I prefer to keep the descriptlor,s� of the facades and archltWural designs as are currently written in the Carlllan Zuning Booklet to ensure the continued cohesiveness of the development. Please do not change our beeUW0l development, where many homes have already been built or comm1 ted to, for the desire of a builder or 1-3 potential home owners, Unfortunately. I will be away on a business trip the evening of the meeting on this matter_ Otherwise I would be in attiandanee. Thank you for helping protect our neigh bcrhood and investment in outihlake. Ryan Reger 1833 RJviera Lane outhlake TX 7 092 817-6 76-4289 Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 29 :PAW015 C i.aaNysk8u-us MEII - F& rhK-k Fa PLlic Haarlrg IPUrle or SOUTHLAKE Holly Slake 4hblake ci,squi[Ijil Ce.tx_us;p Feedback For Public Hearing 1 message Ervl n Let _ Reply -To. Ervin Lee To; 'hblako pl,southlake.tx-us" <hb�ake&l.southlake.tx_us;, Please see our comments below along with our name and addressL Ervin Lee and Lorraine Merriman Lee 1821 Rlvi$ra Lane Southla ke YX 76092 917-488-8028 Comments; Thu. Feb v, 2015 at V 4 AM We are very rnuch apposed to the proposal to allow standing seam rnetal roofs_ We beileve strongly [hat we continue with the existing look and feel that hsv been in place since construction started in the Carlllon_ We think this Changed approved would impact the value and equity of the exlsting homes. Happy to discuss further. Thanks for your time, support and hard work on this luue. Be well, Ervin Lee Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 30 February 5. 20 1 To the Members of 5outhlake Planr}ing and Zoning Commtrre-E My name is Denise Shirey, my husband and i are residents of Carillon. I was one -i the three residents that attended the last meeting for the proposed zoning changes in Carillon. I spoke at the meeting to say my husband and i are against the proposed changes. After the meeting, representatives of the developer spoke with me and the other two residents that attended the meeting. When asked, I told them that my husband and I would be pleased if they removed the proposed change far the "Contemporary" style of a,rthftecture. We do not feel that it would blend with the overall look of our neighborhood. It Ymuld definitely clash with the already approved styles for the estate section and the villas of our neighborhood, which Cave an "old world" look to them. I also told them that i am not in favor of the metal standing seem roof material_ that they are requesting a variance for. did hcwever tell them if we must compromise that my husband and i would not object to specific colors approved by the cfty that are non -reflective and in dark, muted earth tones, I also stated that I would like the average raof pitch of the neighborhood [o be rmaintained which would eliminate the low pitch or flat roofs that have a "Contemporary" or "Frank Lloyd Wright" Look. Outing this conversation i specifically stated that I was 5Wking.for my husband and_myself only, I was not represe [fng ally other residents in the development. The ether two married residents still objected the use of metal standing seem roofs. Rp!gently, the developer sent and email blast to every resident_of the Carilton that i feel was intentionally mWeading an dul ljkto�us. In the email they it inuated that ail. the residents at the meetirq �were armenabie to the standing. seem roof material. Let me remfnd you that there were only 3 reMdents in atten6anee at the corrversatfon after the meeting, two of whom are married and live in the same household. vi'ncerely, _ Si g hirewy Saint Philp Ave., Carillnuthlake Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 31 2iMD CLaoulhla8e,tx-E Mail-ZaringpropaeEr - Cardlar 19 crrr Or SCKMHolly Blake <hblake ci,southlake.tx,us;� Zoning proposal - Carillon message Mike j. Bunch Wed, Feb 4, 2015 at 2- p PM Toe hblake@6,-3oumfeku.tc_u9 Dear Zoning and Planning Commissloner. I am writing to you with cancsrn over the proposed zanWg change In our dwealoprnerlt for the alowanoe of standing seem' metal rooflrig. SWlfi�ally, proposed zoning duwW nniendrrrent 7A-15002. As a SoutMake rvesiderd and community volunteer, l chose to live In Carillon for the developer and bLdlders master plan and architectural plans. The vintage appeal and consistency adds to Me general neighborhood environment and helps protect our Investment. Metal roofs generally are constructed on uber coneervetive homes and krrverrent werclhousing facNlties. In short, It contradicts the canstltuGon of the Cerlllon hrand. I am hopeful that consideration to theamendmerit to not Inclode these rnetal raafs ie stricken irr a decisiva manner, Proponerr1:8 of such obluse materisls to rud their horns, will most likely have other changes in mind that compromise M clean and crisp aes"i; of the homes in the Villes and Est2tea of Carillon. Thank you very much. Sincerely, Mike J. Bush 214-980-8300 Car [kn resk%nl since Ocicber 2013 Case No. Attachment F ZA15-002 Page 32