Loading...
Item 7JCity of Southlake Department of Planning STAFF REPORT October 11, 2006 CASE NO: ZA06 -155 PROJECT: Site Plan for Noble Oaks Park, Lot 1, Block 6, Versailles Addition REQUEST: The City of Southlake is requesting the approval of a Site Plan for Noble Oaks Park located at 1080 S. Carroll Avenue, east of Old Union Elementary School. The proposed improvements include the addition of a park pavilion, a well, pond improvements, and landscaping. The proposed design creates a more useable and attractive pond area with gradual slopes. The park pavilion is to be made of dry stacked stone columns with a green shingle roof. The proposed improvements to Noble Oaks Park was approved by the Park Board (8- 0) at their August 14, 2006 Meeting and approved by the SPDC (6 -0) on September 5, 2006. The Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval (6 -0) of the proposed Site Plan on October 5, 2006. ACTION NEEDED: 1. Conduct public hearing 2. Consider site plan approval ATTACHMENTS: (A) Background Information (B) Vicinity Map (C) Plans and Support Information (D) Surrounding Property Owners Map (E) Surrounding Property Owners Responses STAFF CONTACT: Ken Baker (748 -8067) Jay Narayana (748 -8070) Case No. ZA06 -155 BACKGROUND INFORMATION OWNER: APPLICANT: City of Southlake City of Southlake PROPERTY SITUATION: 1080 S. Carroll Avenue LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 1, Block 6, Versailles Addition LAND USE CATEGORY: Public Parks /Open Space CURRENT ZONING: Residential Planned Unit Development "R -PUD" HISTORY: This property was zoned as part of the Versailles R -PUD in 1994 and platted and dedicated to the city as a city park in 1995. No improvements have been made to the park since its dedication to the city. WATER & SEWER: A well is proposed with the improvements to allow for a constant water level in the pond. P &Z ACTION: October 5, 2006; Approved (6 -0) as presented subject to the staff report. STAFF COMMENTS: Due to the limited nature of the proposed improvements, there is no specific site plan review summary generated for this project. However, due to the impact on mature trees in the vicinity of the pond improvements, the city's Landscape Administrator will work with Community Services staff to realign any utilities, easements, or improvements to minimize the impact on any trees. M \Community Development \MEMO \2006cases \06- 155SP.doc Case No. ZA06 -155 Attachment A Page 1 Vicinity Map Noble oaks Park m f � pxvR! 1000 0 1000 2000 3000 Feet Case No. Attachment B ZA06 -155 Page 1 Detailed Vicinity Map Noble Oaks Park Case No. Attachment B ZA06 -155 Page 2 w O �a Site/Landscape Plan ICili CONTACT JIT.! GOYC. PNOIS P 1504 COO FOO 1[ 1517 -7il� LE M TIE CRY R S011Il POT A 'fam IX THE S011LOOl9 AT SOT DONE! PAM WHICH ME TO BE UZO FM 7H9 PROJECT GPPROMMLY 2.0 MlP9 FROM TIM PROJECT LOCATgM - SEE YICTTTY MAP OM COYER SKEET] II II � AQUATIC YEOETATION evtN.r: r BOLLOM p® (�� �S � 1111• J1 / /.:: Case No. Attachment C ZA06 -155 Page 1 0•: '�/ F 1 �I� :•.I, O r mill �r Case No. Attachment C ZA06 -155 Page 1 Proposed Park Pavilion Elevation GOX 20 SP STRUCTURAL PANEL DECKING SHINGLE ROOFING NO ORNAMENTATION H4818F12 CUPOLA . APPRMM ,, E Case No. Attachment C ZA06 -155 Page 2 Surrounding Property Owners Noble Oaks Park Case No. ZA06 -155 925 9215 927 928 929 930 942 943 939 949 944 924 952 953 954 955 932 140 945 938 939 923 933 946 959 9515 937 922 950 957 934 935 9315 947 929 949 958 920 948 959 9150 9159 9152 9153 9154 9155 27 28 29 30 39 32 33 34 35 315 215 37 515 57 58 59 150 77 905 25 38 24 715 75 74 159 78 904 39 73 152 79 903 40 9015 72 153 8o 902 159 70 79 49 907 154 89 909 908 155 158 157 1515 82 900 42 43 83 99 44 909 84 89 gg 98 990 47 85 97 46 999 90 87 48 415 815 915 992 99 53 993 92 93 94 95 49 50 59 52 54 994 55 995 915 9915 997 998 999 99 98 97 92 95 93 94 3 2 29 20 23 99 22 4 5 15 7 8 90 Attachment D Page 1 Owner Zoning Future Land Use Acreage 1. La, Samuel S & Jane J SF -20A Medium Density Residential 0.475 2. Firestone, John & Daphne SF -20A Medium Density Residential 0.497 3. Latt, Ernest SF -20A Medium Density Residential 0.483 4. Clifford, Kevin J R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.257 5. Vedra, Patrick A & Jennifer R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.257 6. Morgan, Roger Kent & Susan R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.257 7. Allison, James D & Cathy R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.257 8. Palmersheim, Thomas & Donna R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.257 9. Herrmann, David P & Stephan R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.307 10. Carpenter, Scott M & Carol R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.487 11. Timarron Owners Association R -PUD Medium Density Residential 1.017 12. Amlani, Rahim R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.347 13. Jones, Jeffrey D & Patricia R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.61 14. Versailles Ltd R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.034 15. Karant, William & Andrea R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.406 16. Kemp, Randy & Mary Sue R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.489 17. Hudgins, Lisa R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.41 18. Adams, Edward J & Donna T R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.355 19. Birk, Donald & Elizabeth R -PUD Medium Density Residential 0.361 20. City of Southlake RPUD Public Parks / Open Space 5.006 21. Carroll ISD R -PUD Public / Semi -Public 15.044 22. Wilerson, Terry R -PUD Office Commercial 0.87 23. Noble Oaks Partners S -P -1 Medium Density Residential 1.259 Property Owners Outside 200 -feet but within the same Platted Subdivision 24. Versailles Homeowners Assoc R -PUD Medium Density Residential 25. Keeter, Charles W & Patricia A R -PUD Medium Density Residential 26. Bush, John R Jr R -PUD Medium Density Residential 27. Wyman, Lee Grey & Kirsten W R -PUD Medium Density Residential 28. Hyatt, Christopher E & Lynn R -PUD Medium Density Residential 29. Mongelli, Charles & Maria R -PUD Medium Density Residential 30. Barr, William D & Katherine R -PUD Medium Density Residential 31. Shrout, Bradley W & Monique R -PUD Medium Density Residential 32. Dyche, Scott A & Patricia R -PUD Medium Density Residential 33. Gradidge, Christopher & Ter R -PUD Medium Density Residential 34. Horn, Robert I & Julie S R -PUD Medium Density Residential 35. Arent, Stacy & Susan T R -PUD Medium Density Residential 36. Gumm, Steven Lee & Regina R -PUD Medium Density Residential 37. Ball, Thomas E & Priscilla R -PUD Medium Density Residential 38. Gardner, Donald J & Pamela R -PUD Medium Density Residential 39. Haman, R Mark & Marcia C R -PUD Medium Density Residential 40. Byeman, Fred J & Nadine J R -PUD Medium Density Residential 41. Hale, Thomas W & Rita K R -PUD Medium Density Residential Case No. ZA06 -155 Attachment D Page 2 42. Lacey, William F R -PUD Medium Density Residential 43. Weiss, Jonathon G R -PUD Medium Density Residential 44. Berutti, Thomas & Kara R -PUD Medium Density Residential 45. Wang, William & Linda Lee R -PUD Medium Density Residential 46. Scjumacher, Kurt & Greta R -PUD Medium Density Residential 47. Wyble, Charles B & Julia T R -PUD Medium Density Residential 48. Votaw, Timothy B & Mary Jo R -PUD Medium Density Residential 49. Bennett, David & Mary R -PUD Medium Density Residential 50. Do, Ivy Du R -PUD Medium Density Residential 51. Draper, W Curtis & Donna M R -PUD Medium Density Residential 52. Maenza, Tano J & Nancy B R -PUD Medium Density Residential 53. Cantrell, Michael W & Jill R -PUD Medium Density Residential 54. Carter, Barry & Karen D R -PUD Medium Density Residential 55. McKenna, William J & Robin R -PUD Medium Density Residential 56. Crawford, John & Jeriann R -PUD Medium Density Residential 57. Wright, Michael & Dania R -PUD Medium Density Residential 58. Wright, William H & C P R -PUD Medium Density Residential 59. Lair, James A & Marcia L R -PUD Medium Density Residential 60. Poore, Richard W & Susan A R -PUD Medium Density Residential 61. Schonewald, Klaus & Selma K R -PUD Medium Density Residential 62. Rybak, Mark K & Tracy L R -PUD Medium Density Residential 63. Rasmussen, Richard & Amy D R -PUD Medium Density Residential 64. Lowenstein, G A & Kathryn R -PUD Medium Density Residential 65. Rubin, Ronald S & Nancy R -PUD Medium Density Residential 66. Mason, Perry H III & Pamela R -PUD Medium Density Residential 67. Sanchez, Fernando & Irene R -PUD Medium Density Residential 68. Campanello, John & Laura R -PUD Medium Density Residential 69. Behan, John T & Margaret Z R -PUD Medium Density Residential 70. Baughman, Dale T & Jacquely R -PUD Medium Density Residential 71. Gentrup, Michael L & Antoin R -PUD Medium Density Residential 72. Byerly, Stephanie I R -PUD Medium Density Residential 73. Ballew, Read L & Patricia R -PUD Medium Density Residential 74. Pullen, Rodney & Marilyn R -PUD Medium Density Residential 75. Devine, Jeffrey & Jennifer R -PUD Medium Density Residential 76. Bond, Scott G & Janey L R -PUD Medium Density Residential 77. Badura, Bryan & Michele R -PUD Medium Density Residential 78. Purnell, Scott C & Gretchen R -PUD Medium Density Residential 79. Hall, Hu R -PUD Medium Density Residential 80. Cobb, Milo G & Kristine L R -PUD Medium Density Residential 81. Wilhelm, Dennis F & Shirley R -PUD Medium Density Residential 82. Ensch, Randal E & Jennifer R -PUD Medium Density Residential 83. Ross, Cameron & Joanne R -PUD Medium Density Residential 84. Winters, Angela C R -PUD Medium Density Residential 85. Noetzel, Steven & Kelly R -PUD Medium Density Residential Case No. ZA06 -155 Attachment D Page 3 86. Gonzalez, Albert & Jacqueli R -PUD Medium Density Residential 87. Dealy, R P & Jennifer L R -PUD Medium Density Residential 88. Maher, Carol A & John F R -PUD Medium Density Residential 89. Heuring, Nancy R -PUD Medium Density Residential 90. Wray, Billy & Alice R -PUD Medium Density Residential 91. Kay, Tyson & Isabelle R -PUD Medium Density Residential 92. Schupler, Joseph A & Serena R -PUD Medium Density Residential 93. Neal, Michael & Sylvia R -PUD Medium Density Residential 94. Weimer, Christopher & Janet R -PUD Medium Density Residential 95. Cerny, Michael & L Andersen R -PUD Medium Density Residential 96. Pearson, Steven R & Carolyn R -PUD Medium Density Residential 97. Patchett, Brian & Carrie R -PUD Medium Density Residential 98. Banks, Anthony & Yolanda R -PUD Medium Density Residential 99. Cahill, Glenn & Jill R -PUD Medium Density Residential 100. Johnson, Jerome & Anita R -PUD Medium Density Residential 101. Pecora, Jeffrey & Kathy R -PUD Medium Density Residential 102. Tubbesing, Jens & Ailene R -PUD Medium Density Residential 103. Kennedy, Kelly & Michele R -PUD Medium Density Residential 104. Fischer, Kai & Colleen R -PUD Medium Density Residential 105. Neal, Steven & Christine R -PUD Medium Density Residential 106. Fisher, J F & S M O'Grady R -PUD Medium Density Residential 107. Malhotra, Pamela R -PUD Medium Density Residential 108. Meletis, Efstathios R -PUD Medium Density Residential 109. Zottneck, Scott & Stacey R -PUD Medium Density Residential 110. Bailey, Sidney E Jr & T F R -PUD Medium Density Residential 111. Manskey, James & Kim R -PUD Medium Density Residential 112. Nguyenphu, Thinh & Janet R -PUD Medium Density Residential 113. Seger, Steven & Melanie R -PUD Medium Density Residential 114. Compagnone, Charles & W R -PUD Medium Density Residential 115. Johnson, Oliran & Gay R -PUD Medium Density Residential 116. Cheatham, Kenneth & D R -PUD Medium Density Residential 117. Molduene, Julia & James R -PUD Medium Density Residential 118. Smith, H M & Laura F R -PUD Medium Density Residential 119. Sympson, Robert & Ma R -PUD Medium Density Residential 120. Versailles HOA SF -20B Medium Density Residential 121. Osterberg, Randall & T SF -20B Medium Density Residential 122. Keith, Timothy & Jennifer SF -20B Medium Density Residential 123. Turner, Lori Lynn SF -20B Medium Density Residential 124. Smith, Jeffrey & Sammie SF -20B Medium Density Residential 125. Jameson, David & Sandra SF -20B Medium Density Residential 126. Winter, Robert & Jennifer SF -20B Medium Density Residential 127. Smith, Christopher & Joan SF -20B Medium Density Residential 128. Nguyen, John D & Hien SF -20B Medium Density Residential 129. Brodows, Scott & Cathy SF -20B Medium Density Residential Case No. ZA06 -155 Attachment D Page 4 130. Moritz, Michael SF -20B Medium Density Residential 131. Mobley, Kenneth & Deb SF -20B Medium Density Residential 132. Cahill, Richard M SF -20B Medium Density Residential 133. Choe, Howard C & T SF -20B Medium Density Residential 134. Depinto, Joseph & Ingrid SF -20B Medium Density Residential 135. Reinke, William & Bonnie SF -20B Medium Density Residential 136. Leblanc, Edward & Debbie SF -20B Medium Density Residential 137. Musgrove, Richard & Bar SF -20B Medium Density Residential 138. Griffith, John & Michelle SF -20B Medium Density Residential 139. Su, Charles & Eileen SF -20B Medium Density Residential 140. Hart, Stephen & Christin SF -20B Medium Density Residential 141. Laufenberg, Brandon & J SF -20B Medium Density Residential 142. Aydon, Donald & Michelle SF -20B Medium Density Residential 143. Eudora Holdings LLC SF -20B Medium Density Residential 144. Friedel, Timothy & Donna SF -20B Medium Density Residential 145. Stanfill, Michael & P J SF -20B Medium Density Residential 146. Reed, Michael & Janice SF -20B Medium Density Residential 147. Lamp, David SF -20B Medium Density Residential 148. Faw, Jeffrey & Dorothea SF -20B Medium Density Residential 149. Polanski, Jos & Robyn L SF -20B Medium Density Residential 150. Gill, John & Maria SF -20B Medium Density Residential 151. Doyle, Richard F & Andrea SF -20B Medium Density Residential 152. White, Carol & Thomas SF -20B Medium Density Residential 153. Land, James & John Blake SF -20B Medium Density Residential 154. Thacker, Ronald & Kim SF -20B Medium Density Residential 155. Knight, Michael & Laurel SF -20B Medium Density Residential 156. Haney, Joseph & Wendy SF -20B Medium Density Residential 157. Goin, John & Cheryl SF -20B Medium Density Residential 158. McMillen, Kevin & Lisa SF -20B Medium Density Residential 159. Fennell, John & Anne SF -20B Medium Density Residential 160. Miranda, Jorge & Andrea SF -20B Medium Density Residential 161. Begley, Bryan & Jessica SF -20B Medium Density Residential 162. Clapperton, Peter & Johnna SF -20B Medium Density Residential 163. Terry, David & Sue Terry SF -20B Medium Density Residential 164. Burkhart, Timothy & J SF -20B Medium Density Residential 165. Rich, Jimmy D & Sue Ann SF -20B Medium Density Residential Case No. ZA06 -155 Attachment D Page 5 Surrounding Property Owner Responses Noble Oaks Park Notices Sent Certified Mail: Twenty -Two (22) Notices Sent First Class Mail: One Hundred Forty -Three (143) Responses Receive: None (0) Case No. ZA06 -155 Attachment E Page 1