Item 10ALog Cabin Committee Report to City Council
“This log cabin is the only vestige of our heritage remaining in Southlake besides the city’s five cemeteries.”-Historian Jack Wiesman
Our Freeman Cabin
Built by one of Southlake’s Earliest Settlers John A Freeman
Dates to the 1860’s
Originally located in a stand of oak trees across from Town Square on the Land which is now Central Market
It is a registered Historical Site
15 ft. x 12 ft. Single story one room cabin
Directive from City Council on December 6, 2005
Council established Ordinance No 05-074 creating the Log Cabin Committee to:
Recommend a location for the placement of the historic log cabin as well as potential inclusion of other suitable historic features
Develop a master plan for the placement and programming of the log cabin and other potential historical features
Develop a conceptual plan for the layout of the log cabin and site amenities
Provide detailed cost estimates for log cabin restoration and site amenities
Provide color rendering of the restored log cabin
Investigate potential joint opportunities for planning, construction and operations
Present a final report to City Council with recommendations to include the information listed above within 60 to 90 days
Committee Members
Council Member Laura Hill – Co Chair
Council Member Virginia Muzyka – Co Chair
Carlie Stephenson
C.D Peebles
Dr. Ray Chancellor
Craig Rothmeier
Jason Kasal
Greg Standerfer
F.C LeVrier
Historical Society Member Connie Cooley
Historical Society Member Lou Ann Heath
Parks Board Vice Chair Mike Mills
Parks Board Member Emily Galpin
Steve Polasek – Staff Liaison
Ken Baker – Staff Liaison
December 15, 2005
Reviewed Councils’ directive, background of the Cabins placement and Leadership Southlake study
18 sites were identified by the committee
Sites included City, Private and CISD owned properties
Committee members encouraged to tour each site before the second meeting and to consider each criteria while touring
Setting Weighted Criteria
Before the second meeting every committee member submitted a ranking of each criteria to City Staff
Each criteria was assigned a “weight “ based on a computer tally/average of the votes
Security
Ease of Access
Topography
Expense related to development
Proximity to a destination location
Potential for future growth
Safety for running/playing children
Handicap Accessibility
Fits with the setting
Visibility
Parking
Drainage
January 12, 2006
Each potential site was reviewed and all positives and challenges were listed
Using the computer, each criteria was voted on for each location by every committee member
All 12 criteria were voted on for all 18 locations
4 top sites were selected based on the vote results
Bicentennial Park (Bunker Hill), Bicentennial Park (West Side), Summit Park and Noble Oaks
Bicentennial West Side was unanimously rejected due to the time frame for development
January 12, Second Vote
The 3 top sites were discussed again and another vote, by criteria was taken
The committee voted to move forward with the top 2 sites, Bicentennial and Summit Park which received substantially more votes than Noble Oaks
Committee members voted to add and rank 8 additional criteria making the total criteria considered 20
Setting consistent with cabin era
Sites historical significance
Additional area for subsistence farming plot
Promotes tourism
Fits in as part of an educational setting/area
Appeal to Visitors
Synergy with adjacent facilities
Positive impact on adjacent landowners, residents and businesses
February 6, 2006
The Committee toured each site as a group
The site visits provided Committee members an opportunity to better evaluate the feasibility of each location and to discuss as a group various aspects in more detail
February 20, 2006
Using the 20 site selection criteria developed and weighted by all Committee members, Bicentennial Park and Summit Park were individually scored by all 13 Committee members
All criteria votes were entered into the computer
Summit Park 414 points (20.9)
Bicentennial Park 429 points (21.6)
The lower score represents the more favorable location
Southlake’s Summit Park
Has some of our most beautiful mature Park trees and scenic vistas in keeping with the cabins original location across the street
The cabin would be best placed on the western slope, away from the Brownstones and at the entrance to Summit Park facing Central Avenue
Additional space is available for future possible placement of farm implements or artifacts
Opportunities to use the existing park trail to place etched natural stone markers, describing Southlake’s history. Intended to blend with the setting and serve as a self guided walking
tour
Conceptual Plan
Utilize existing mature trees as a backdrop
Recommend additional dense landscaping to buffer to the north from Main Street and offer greater site line to Central Avenue
Use native grasses, shrubs and wildflowers, crushed granite walkways and dry stack rocks
Added amenities may include; low level security/accent lighting, replica water well, etched stone signage and a historical walking tour.
Budget
COST ESTIMATE:
The cost estimates for the placement of the log cabin are a function of the proposed site plan as provided by Schrickel, Rollins and Associates. The log cabin restoration costs were
provided by the Southlake Historical Society and are based on initial estimates provided by Bill Marquis who performed the restoration of the log cabin in Euless.
Total Estimate $90,486.88
Recommendations
Placement of the cabin in Summit Park at the site depicted in the proposed site plan
Identification and allocation of funding for the re-construction of the log cabin and the addition of site amenities as depicted
Seek participation from the Southlake Historical Society and Cooper and Stebbins in the final design and re-construction
Explore an expanded partnership with the Southlake Historical Society for the ongoing upkeep and maintenance
Promote the Cabin’s historical significance to our community through written documents, on the City web-site and through programming opportunities
Thank You
The Cabin Committee appreciates the opportunity to serve our citizens and City Council through our review, research and development of this final report
We wish to acknowledge the preceding efforts of previous Councils, the Southlake Historical Society, the Parks and Recreation Board and Leadership Southlake Class of 2003-2004.
We are grateful to City Staff, especially Steve Polasek and Ken Baker for their untiring support and countless hours on this communities behalf
We appreciate this Councils support and trust in our abilities and representation
Honoring Our Past
“ As families through out time have lived in their homes, they have always made room for memories of days gone by to sit among the possessions of today. This cabin is our memory of
days gone by………may we always remember those who came before us to establish this community that we all call home. “