Item 4DItem 4D ZA07-080
OWNER: Jerry Mills
APPLICANT: Tri-Tech DFW Surveying
REQUEST: Approval of a Zoning Change and Concept Plan from “AG” Agricultural District to “SF-30” Single Family Residential District for the development of one residential lot of 0.94
acre.
LOCATION: The property is located at 1090 Primrose Ln.
Primrose Lane
N. Carroll Ave
View looking south towards property
Primrose Lane
Item 4D ZA07-080
Overall Site Data
Gross Acreage: 1.00 acres
Net Acreage: 0.94 acres
Area of R.O.W.: 0.06 acres
Number of Lots: 1 lots
Gross Density: 1.00 du/acre
Net Density: 1.06 du/acre
Avg. Lot Size: 0.94 acres (41,000 sq. ft.)
Concept Plan
Concept Plan
Questions?
Public Works Presentation
Item 7B ZA07-085
OWNER: Terra Shady Oaks
APPLICANT: Sage Group
REQUEST: Approval of first reading for a zoning change and concept plan from "AG" Agricultural District to "SF-20A" Single Family Residential District. The plan proposes the development
of 136 single-family residential lots and 18 open space lots on approximately 96.3 acres.
LOCATION: The property is located at 820 Shady Oaks Drive.
Required C2U
(60’ R-O-W)
W. Highland St.
Shady Oaks Dr
N. Peytonville Ave
Southridge Lakes Pkwy
Coventry
Southridge Lakes
Raven Bend
Cross
Timber
Hills
Sandlin Manor
View looking east toward property
View looking west toward property
Views looking across Shady Oaks Dr
Views looking across N. Peytonville Ave
ZA07-085 & ZA07-086
Overall Site Data
1st Plan 2nd Plan
Gross Acreage: 96.3 acres 96.3 acres
Net Acreage: 78.8 acres 82.3 acres
Area of R.O.W.: 17.5 acres 14.0 acres
Number of Lots: 149 lots 154 lots
- 136 single family - 136 single family
- 13 open space - 18 open space
Open Space: 5.48 acres (5.69%) 8.77 acres (9.11%)
Gross Density: 1.41 du/acre 1.41 du/acre
Net Density: 1.73 du/acre 1.65 du/acre
Avg. Lot Size: 0.54 acres 0.54 acres
(23,484 sq. ft.) (23,551 sq. ft.)
Previously Proposed Concept Plan
Previously Proposed Tree Conservation Plan
Revised Concept Plan
Redesigned plan to
eliminate all
cul-de-sac streets
Increased the open
space area by ±3.29
acres (3.42% increase)
Revised Tree Conservation Plan
Increased tree preservation
of 75 trees (from 71% to 83%)
Area of desired preservation
Per the City’s ERP Map
Revised Tree Conservation Plan
Revised Concept Plan
Proposed “Collector” does not meet street geometry requirements
for collector roadways
* Minimum 400’ radius required
* Minimum 50’ tangent length required
Carroll ISD Involvement
CISD’s 2007 Demographics Report projected 52 developed lots on this property by 2011 and 178 lots by 2016
CISD officials met with the developer on three different occasions regarding traffic patterns and number of lots
* Estimate based on 136 units and district-wide average student-to-household ratio
(0.88 students per household) and district-wide average distribution of student age
(35% for Elementary students, 16% for Intermediate students).
Estimated Development Impact on Durham
Traffic Impact Analysis
New Collector at Build-Out
Previously Proposed Preliminary Plat
Item 7B ZA07-085
P&Z ACTION: August 23, 2007; Approved (5-1) subject to Concept Plan Review Summary No. 3, dated August 17, 2007; granting the requested variances.
Questions?
Public Works Presentation
Previously Submitted Utility Plan
Previously Submitted Drainage Plan
Concept Plan
Tree Survey
Items 7C & 7D ZA07-097 & ZA07-098
OWNER/
APPLICANT: Keller Watermere, L.P. & Southlake Watermark Holdings, L.P.
REQUEST: Approval of first reading for a Zoning Change and Concept Plan to add approximately 4 acres of “AG” Agricultural District to the existing “S-P-2” Generalized Site Plan District
for the South Village at Watermere to add 28 cottage (independent living) units. Also remove approximately 2 acres from the existing S-P-2 boundary.
Approval of first reading for a Zoning Change and Development Plan from “AG” Agricultural District to “R-PUD” Residential Planned Unit Development District. The plan proposes 54 single-family
residential detached lots and 6 open space lots on approximately 30 acres.
LOCATION: The property is located at 2271 Union Church Rd, 2811 W Southlake Blvd, 2809 W Southlake Blvd, 2815 W Southlake Blvd, 2801 W Southlake Blvd, 2477 Union Church Rd, 2451 Union
Church Rd.
Proposed LUP Amendment
From Public/Semi Public (Blue) to
Medium Density Residential (Orange)
Original SP-2
New zoning
change request
Original SP-2
New SP-2
boundary
New PUD
View looking west toward property
View looking east toward property
View looking north toward property
Union Church Rd
ZA07-097 & ZA07-098
Overall Site Data
Original S-P-2 New S-P-2 R-PUD Total
Gross Acreage: 33.53 ac ±36 acres ±30 acres 65.53 acres
Cottages (Villas) 85 units 113 units (+28) --- units 113 units
Condos 152 units 152 units --- units 152 units
Personal Care 60 units 60 units --- units 60 units
Memory/Nursing 40 units 40 units --- units 40 units
Residential (Detached) --- lots --- lots 54 lots 54 lots
337 units 365 units 54 lots 419 units/lots
Density: 10.06 du/acre 10.2 du/acre 1.79 du/acre 6.39 du/acre
Open Space: 16.77 ac 16.44 ac 9.52 ac 25.96 ac
Open Space %: 50% 46% 32% 40%
Previously Approved Concept Plan
Overall Concept Plan
Concept Plan
Area added to “S-P-2” zoning
Area of “R-PUD” zoning
Color Concept Plan
Color Concept Plan – Amenities Center
Color Concept Plan
Color Concept Plan
Color Concept Plan
Pedestrian Access Plan
8 ft sidewalk
6 ft sidewalk
5 ft sidewalk
Landscape Plan
Overall
Fence Plan
Tree Conservation Analysis
Concept Plan
New area of “S-P-2” zoning
Item 7C ZA07-097
Current Zoning: Proposed Zoning:
Gross/Net Acreage: 33.53 acres ± 36 acres
# of units:
-Cottages (Villas) 85 units 113 units
-Condos (Retirement Res.) 152 units 152 units
-Personal Care 60 units 60 units
-Memory/Nursing 40 units 40 units
337 units 365 units
Density: 10 du/acre 10.2 du/acre
The development will follow all regulations and design criteria of the currently approved Watermere project.
Item 7C ZA07-097 (Additional SP-2 Area)
Overall Site Data
Gross Acreage: ±4 acres
Net Acreage: ±4 acres
Number of Lots: 1 lot
Number of structures: 7 four-unit structures
Number of Units: 28 cottages (single family attached)
Parking Required: 28 spaces (1 space per unit)
Parking Provided: 28 spaces
Open Space: ±35% (1.4 acres)
Impervious Cover: ±65% (2.3 acres)
Conceptual Cottage (4-plex) Elevation
Conceptual Cottage (4-plex) Elevation
Cottage Elevations (under construction in Phase 1)
Cottage Elevations (under construction in Phase 1)
Cottage Elevations (under construction in Phase 1)
Conceptual Cottage (4-plex) Materials
Item 7D ZA07-098
The “R-PUD” zoning proposes to comply with the “SF-20A” Single Family Residential District permitted uses and development regulations with the following exceptions:
Min. Lot Size: 9,800 square feet
Min. Lot Width: 70 feet at the front building line
Min. Lot Depth: 130 feet
Min. Floor Area: 2,500 square feet
Min. Front Yard: 25 feet
Min. Side Yard: 7 feet;
15 feet for corner lot adjacent to street
Min. Rear Yard: 25 feet for exterior lots;
20 feet for interior lots
Max. Lot Coverage: 60% (Variance from 30% allowed)
Min. Garage Setback: 25 feet forward facing;
20 feet swing
Item 7D ZA07-098
“R-PUD” Site Data
Gross Acreage: 30.1 acres
Net Acreage: ±28.2 acres
Number of Lots: 62 lots
- 54 single family (detached)
- 6 open space
- 2 private street
Open Space: 9.52 acres (32%)
Gross Density: 1.79 du/acre
Net Density: 1.91 du/acre
Avg. Lot Size: 0.38 acres (16,600 sq. ft.)
Concept Plan
Area of “R-PUD” zoning
Concept Plan
Area of “R-PUD” zoning
Requesting variance to street frontage requirement.
The applicant is requesting that all lots front on a
common access easement (private street)
Conceptual Single Family Detached Elevation
Conceptual Single Family Detached Elevations
Preliminary Plat
View from Southlake Boulevard
View from Southlake Boulevard
View from Lakeside Presbyterian
View from Lakeside Presbyterian
View from Union Church
View of Union Church at the Watermere Site
View of Union Church at the Watermere Site
View of Union Church at the Watermere Site
View of Union Church at the Watermere Site
Questions?
Public Works Presentation
Preliminary Utility Plan
Preliminary Drainage Plan
Concept Plan
Items 7C & 7D ZA07-097 & ZA07-098
P&Z ACTION: ZA07-097: August 9, 2007; Approved (6-0) subject to Concept Plan Review Summary No. 1, dated August 17, 2007.
ZA07-098: August 9, 2007; Approved (6-0) subject to Development Plan Review Summary No. 1, dated August 17, 2007; granting the requested variance.
Questions?
ZA07-097 & ZA07-098 (SP-2)
ZA06-045
OWNER/
APPLICANT: Robert & Sara Gray
REQUEST: 1) Approval of a change of zoning from “RE” Single Family Residential Estate District to “SF-1A” Single Family Residential District on approximately 2.10 acres.
LOCATION: The property is located at 520 W. Highland Street and 1275 Shady Oaks Drive.
View looking south toward property
Highland
Shady Oaks
Aerial
Original RE Lot
New SF-1A Lot
Zoning
Change
Request
Portion rezoned to
R-PUD in 2006
ZA06-045
Site Data (Zoning Change)
Gross Land Area: 2.00 acres (Zoning Change)
Net Land Area: 2.00 acres
Number of Lots: 1 lots
Gross Density: 0.25 du/acre
Net Density: 0.25 du/acre
Average Lot Size: 4.005 acres (174,458 sq. ft.) (Resulting SF-1A lot)
Item 7E ZA06-045
P&Z ACTION: May 18, 2006; Approved (5-0) as presented.
Questions?
Item 9A SP07-275
APPLICANT: Victory Awning on behalf of Michael Anthony’s
LOCATION: 2750 East Southlake Boulevard, Suite 140
REQUEST: Variance to the Gateway Plaza Phase II (Wyndham Plaza) Conditional Sign Permit for attached signs. The applicant is proposing to add an awning with attached lettering on 3
sides.
Site Exhibit
Proposed Awning
Proposed Awning
Initials on front
“Steaks, Chops and Seafood” on both sides
Awning will be black - All lettering will be white
Awning Details – Front View
Awning will be black with white lettering
Awning Details – Side View
Awning will be black with white lettering
Awning Details – Overhead View
Current View
Current View
Adjacent Signs
Adjacent Signs
Item 9A SP07-275
QUESTIONS?
Ordinance 480-QQQ1st Reading
Residential Accessory Structure & POD Standards
Item 7A
Background
City Council directed staff to review accessory structure standards in residential zoning district
Staff discussed options with P&Z and proposed changes in Fall of 2006 (Ordinance 480-OOO)
Concerns were raised with the proposed standards for accessory structures and POD’s during the public hearings
In November 2006, City Council redirected staff to discuss options with P & Z
Background
P&Z has had several work sessions on this item in January and February of 2007
Reviewed information on existing accessory structures on AG, RE, and SF-1A zoning districts
Reviewed information on variances to accessory building size standards by ZBA
Reviewed other localities POD ordinances
AG Zoned Lots
AG Zoned Lots
RE Zoned Lots
RE Zoned Lots
SF-1A Zoned Lots
SF-1A Zoned Lots
Current Standards forResidential Accessory Structures
Residential districts:
Area limitation of:
10% lot coverage for AG districts;
5% lot coverage for RE districts;
1,000 s.f. for SF-1;
600 s.f. for SF-20 & SF-30 districts; and
Flexible for PUDs.
Other standards (apply to both residential and commercial districts):
Setbacks from property lines and principal structures
Limited to 14 feet in height
Location limited to behind the principal structure
Structures in excess of the area limitation require ZBA approval
Summary of Changes
Clarification of definitions
Specific standards for “minor” accessory structures in all zoning districts
Revised standards for accessory structures in SF-1A zoning district
Addition of design criteria for ZBA review of larger accessory structures
POD Regulations
Definitions
Distinction made between ACCESSORY BUILDING OR STRUCTURE and ACCESSORY USE
PORTABLE ON-DEMAND STORAGE DEVICES (PODs)
Standards for “minor” residential accessory structures in all residential zoning districts
Section 34 – Accessory Uses
Permitted in the front yard, side yard, or rear yard:
Gazebos, arbors, pergolas, trellises, water well houses, fountains, ponds, and ornamental pools
Minor Accessory Structures
Not permitted in the front yard:
Batting cages, play structures, and pet houses
Breezeways
Decks and play courts
SF-1A Accessory Structure Standards
Maximum cumulative area = 3% of the lot
Accessory structures under 750 sq.ft. – current standards apply (Section 34.2)
Accessory structures between 750 sq.ft. and 3% shall meet the following standards:
Principal structure setback apply
Height shall not exceed 20 feet
Design Standards apply
Design Standards
Accessory structures of metal, wood or vinyl siding or equivalent material shall meet the following design standards:
Minimum of 2 colors
All metal accessory buildings to be painted with a factory applied non-metallic matte-finish
Addition of trim detail around the windows/doors/or string courses or water tables
Windows, doors, or other openings required on at least 2 sides
Pitched roof required (of the appropriate pitch for the roof design chosen or a minimum of 1:3)
Design Standards
Accessory structures using masonry shall meet the following standards:
Masonry material (brick, stone, stucco) used shall match the masonry material of the principal structure on the lot
Addition of trim detail around the windows/doors/or string courses or water tables
Windows, doors, or other openings required on at least 2 sides
Roof (design, pitch, and materials) to be the same type as the principal structure roof
Review of Accessory Structures over 3% of the lot area
ZBA review criteria:
Compatibility of the materials proposed with the principal structures and the surrounding properties
Purpose of the accessory structure
Consistency of architectural style including roof structure
Setback from adjoining properties and location on the subject property
Other factors that may apply
Standards for PODs
PODs for residential moving
PODs for residential remodeling and construction
POD Standards-Temporary Storage
Portable on demand (POD) storage units for temporary residential storage during moving meeting the following standards:
PODs shall be placed on the driveway at the furthest point from the street
PODs cannot be placed on any public right-of-way or in the front yard
Each residential lot shall be limited to two (2) PODs at a time; no more than twice per calendar year to be placed no longer than ten (10) consecutive days each time
No permit shall be required for PODs used for temporary storage during moving
POD Standards-Residential Remodeling
Portable on demand (POD) storage units for use during residential remodeling and construction meeting the following standards:
PODs shall be placed on the driveway at the furthest point from the street
PODs cannot be placed on any public right-of-way or in the front yard
A permit shall be required with the building permit for remodeling/construction and shall be valid for the duration of the building permit only.
An application for the building permit shall indicate the location of the POD units on the lot.
PODs shall be removed within seven (7) days of final inspection of the structure.
Questions?