Loading...
Item 7B - Parking Analysis & Offsite Parking AgreementCarrillo Engineering C-111. Engineering LLC — Technical Memorandum To: Mr. Dennis Killough Director of Planning and Development Services City of Southlake From: Anna L. Carrillo, P.E. Carrillo Engineering, LLC Registered Firm # 15893 Date: April 26, 2016 Revised January 23, 2026 9001 Airport Freeway Suite 700 North Richland Hills, TX 76180 817-697-4996 anna.carrillo@carrilloeng.com Subject: Update to Parking Study of Westin Hotel in Southlake, Texas prepared by Carrillo Engineering on April 26, 2016 Introduction A new event space building addition is being proposed at the existing Westin Hotel located at 1200 E State Hwy 114. The proposed addition will primarily be a social meeting / banquet space to be focused on weddings, luncheons, presentations, and other social events. The breakdown of space will consist of 3,615 square feet of meeting space; 385 square feet of restrooms; 161 square feet of green room; 215 square feet of storage; and 589 square feet of back -of house for a total of gross building area of 5,017 square feet. A site plan is provided at the end of this memorandum for reference. The back of house areas have resulted in a reduction of 7 parking spaces in the parking garage. However, it is important to note that the upper level of the parking garage, which contains 125 parking spaces, is very rarely used. In addition, the proposed event space will mostly be used for social events on weekends, which are times when the hotel's existing meeting space is not being used. Therefore, even if those parking spaces were utilized for conferences, their use would not coincide with the use of the proposed event center. As requested by the City of Southlake (City), the purpose of this technical memorandum is to update the previous parking analysis by summarizing the changes in square footage due to the proposed event space and therefore, the revised parking needs for the Westin Hotel, if any. The square footage for conference space (3,615 square feet) was updated on the floor space assumptions and parking demand comparisons in the analysis below. Since restaurant and/or room space will not change, these numbers did not change from the previous analysis. An exception to this is the required number of spaces for hotel use for the City of Grapevine due to its current ordinance requiring one space per room. Proposed Changes When the referenced parking study was prepared in 2016, the proposed number of rooms used in the analysis was 253. The final number of rooms ended up at 261 given the addition of 8 rooms on the south end of the building on the first floor. For the purposes of this update, 261 rooms were used in the tabulations below. Pagel of 4 Carrillo Engineering C-111. Engineering LLC — 9001 Airport Freeway Suite 700 North Richland Hills, TX 76180 817-697-4996 anna.carrillo@carrilloeng.com Similarly, the proposed square footage for Conference/Meeting space was 24,269 square feet and 8,745 square feet, respectively. Table 1. Floor Space Use Assumptions from the previous study has been updated to reflect the addition of 3,615 square feet of conference/meeting space. The values that were changed due to the addition of this space are shown in italics below and are enclosed in a text box for clarity. Table 1. Floor Space Use Assumptions Floor Concept Plan Designation Use Category Development Unit Intensity 1 Ballroom Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 7,823 1 Meeting Room A Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 1,207 1 Meeting Room B Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 1,207 1 Meeting Room C Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 1,207 1 Meeting Room D Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 892 1 Meeting Room E Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 892 1 Pre -function Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 4,179 1 Board Room 1 Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 426 1 Board Room 2 Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 426 1 Event Space Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 7,115 1 Lounge Conference/Mtg. Square Feet 2,510 Total Table 1. Floor Space Use Assumptions below did not change from the previous analysis. Table 1. Floor Space Use Assumptions Floor Concept Plan Designation Use Category Development Unit Intensity 1 Restaurant Restaurant Square Feet 2,926 1 Kitchen Restaurant Square Feet 3,788 1 Private Dining Rooms Restaurant Square Feet 0 1 Kitchen Restaurant Square Feet 2,031 Total 8,745 1-6 Guest Rooms Hotel Rooms 261 Parking Requirements For the intent of determining the parking requirements for the site based on the changes shown in Table 1. Floor Space Use Assumptions, the same criteria described in the original study was used. Requirements for the Cities of Southlake, Dallas, Fort Worth, and Grapevine as well as those established by the Hotel Planning and Development Guide (HP&DG) were considered. Parking requirements of the cities of Southlake, Dallas, and Fort Worth were updated on Table 7. Parking Requirements Comparison from those in the original study as shown below. Given that those of the City of Grapevine and the HP&DG were calculated based on Page 2 of 4 Carrillo Engineering C-111. Engineering LLC — 9001 Airport Freeway Suite 700 North Richland Hills, TX 76180 817-697-4996 anna.carrillo@carrilloeng.com hotel and restaurant uses only and conference/meeting space was not considered, the information on Table 7 for these requirements remained unchanged. However, the City of Grapevine's current off-street parking ordinance requires one parking space per room, which is different than that required at the time of the previous study. Therefore, the number of required spaces for hotel was reduced from 380 spaces to 261 for an overall total required spaces of 348. This represents the lowest total required parking spaces of all cities used in the comparative analysis. The requirements from the HP&DG for low (1.2), median (1.3), and high (1.4) remained unchanged from those in the previous analysis. The updated table is shown below. The values that were changed due to the addition of the proposed event space are shown in italics and are enclosed in a text box for clarity. Table 7. Parking Requirements Comparison Land Use Stalls Required/Demand Calculated Southlake Dallas Fort Worth Grapevine HP&DG 1.2 1.3 1.4 Hotel 261 261 261 261 313 339 365 Conference/Meeting Space 279 140 140 1 - - - - Restaurant 87 44 87 87 87 87 87 Total 627 445 488 348 400 426 452 As noted in the previous study, the City of Southlake requirements are the highest. As in the previous study, the biggest difference is in the Conference/Meeting Space likely because the City of Southlake does not specify a land use for conference or convention centers and also because it treats each use as stand-alone and not as an auxiliary use. This applies to the restaurant requirements as well. This requirement is overestimated given that the event space is auxiliary to the hotel. In addition and as stated above, the proposed event space will mostly be used for social events on weekends, which are times when the hotel's existing meeting space is not being used. Conclusion Based on the update to the parking analysis, we conclude that the Westin Hotel will continue to offer adequate parking for its current use and for the proposed event space addition. Below is a list of points that support this conclusion: The calculations for the City of Southlake show to require the most spaces. However, this is due primarily to the two reasons mentioned earlier: 1) there is not a specific requirement for Conference/Meeting space and when using Community Center, the number is very high, and 2) it treats each use (hotel, community center, and restaurant) as stand-alone uses and not accessory uses. This requirement is overestimated given that the event space is auxiliary to the hotel. In addition and as stated above, the proposed event space will mostly be used for social events on weekends, which are times when the hotel's existing meeting space is not being used. As in the original study, we recommend that the Westin Hotel share an area for overflow parking through an agreement with the Gateway Church. Since the date of the original parking study, a new Page 3 of 4 Carrillo Engineering C-111. Engineering LLC — 9001 Airport Freeway Suite 700 North Richland Hills, TX 76180 817-697-4996 anna.carrillo@carrilloeng.com parking lot has been added by the Gateway Church that is closer to the Westin Hotel site. Shuttling service can be provided during such special events. Gateway Church originally provided a letter dated March 11, 2016 stating their support for the Westin Hotel development and agreement to share parking. A subsequent letter was provided by Gateway Church on January 19, 2026 confirming the continuation of such agreement. The most current letter is attached to this analysis. In the last four years, Gateway Church's shared parking has only been utilized by the Westin Hotel twice. • We understand the actual number of existing parking spaces is 419 and after the reduction of 7 due to the proposed event space, the remaining number will be 412. We find this number to be adequate given that it is 12 spaces higher than the low (1.2) of those recommended by the HP&DG and 64 spaces higher than the lowest of all studied scenarios. • The Westin Hotel has now been in operation for over 4 years and it's operationally proven that the number of parking spaces is more than adequate for the hotel's daily and peak needs. o As mentioned, Gateway Church's shared parking has only been utilized by the Westin Hotel twice since its opening day. o The upper level of the hotel's parking garage has 125 parking spaces which are rarely used. o The proposed event space will be mostly used on weekends, which are times when the hotel's existing meeting space is not being used. Therefore, even if those parking spaces were utilized for conferences, their use would not coincide with the use of the proposed event center. Page 4 of 4 Page is too large to OCR. JGateway CHURCH January 19, 2026 ATT: Mr. Dennis Killough City of Southlake 1400 Main Street Southlake TX 76092 Dear Mr. Killough: RE: Overflow Parking Agreement between Gateway Church and the Westin Hotel located on the corner of Grace Lane and Highway 114 access road, Southlake, Texas. Gateway Church has been asked to send this letter to the city outlining its continued support of the Westin in its overflow parking needs, should the need arise. On behalf of Gateway Church, I can confirm that the church continues to be prepared to provide overflow parking to the hotel, in areas of Gateway's campus agreed between the parties, with adequate notice, understanding that the hotel's demand for parking is most often at times when the church's needs are at lower levels, and therefore has very little or no effect on the church's parking needs. Please contact me if you have any additional questions or need more information Respectfully, Nathan C. Beaman Chief Financial Officer at Gateway Church 500 S. NOLAN DRIVE 1 #300 1 SOLITHLAKE TEXAS 176092 JGateway CHURCH January 19, 2026 ATT: Mr. Dennis Killough City of Southlake 1400 Main Street Southlake TX 76092 Dear Mr. Killough: RE: Overflow Parking Agreement between Gateway Church and the Westin Hotel located on the corner of Grace Lane and Highway 114 access road, Southlake, Texas. Gateway Church has been asked to send this letter to the city outlining its continued support of the Westin in its overflow parking needs, should the need arise. On behalf of Gateway Church, I can confirm that the church continues to be prepared to provide overflow parking to the hotel, in areas of Gateway's campus agreed between the parties, with adequate notice, understanding that the hotel's demand for parking is most often at times when the church's needs are at lower levels, and therefore has very little or no effect on the church's parking needs. Please contact me if you have any additional questions or need more information Respectfully, Nathan C. Beaman Chief Financial Officer at Gateway Church 500 S. NOLAN DRIVE 1 #300 1 SOLITHLAKE TEXAS 176092