Loading...
Item 7 - REVISED 01-05-2022Case No. ZA21-0093 S T A F F R E P O R T January 5, 2022 CASE NO: ZA21-0093 PROJECT: Site Plan for Lonesome Dove Baptist Church Addition EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: On behalf of Lonesome Dove Baptist Church, Kirkman Engineering is requesting approval of a Site Plan for Lonesome Dove Baptist Church Addition on property described as Lot 1R1R, Block 1, Lonesome Dove Baptist Church Addition, an addition to the City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas, and located at 2380 Lonesome Dove Ave. (also called Lonesome Dove Rd.), Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: “CS” Community Service District. SPIN Neighborhood #2. DETAILS: The project is generally located on the west side of Lonesome Dove Ave. approximately 400’ north of Emerald Circle. The west and south property lines abut the Emerald Estates subdivision and the north property line abuts the Lonesome Dove Cemetery. The applicant is requesting approval of a Site Plan to allow an approximately 13,893 square foot worship building with 376 seats to be added on the property. The Site Data Summary Chart is below. Site Data Summary Existing Zoning “CS” Community Service Land Use Designation Public/Semi-Public Gross/Net Acreage 6.708 ac. (292,183 s.f.) Proposed Building Floor Area (Gross) 13,893 Total Building Floor Area (Gross) 30,895 Building Height/Number of Stories 32’-2” and 1 story Open Space % 55.6% Impervious Coverage % 44.4% Total Parking Required (1 per 3 seats) 126 Total Parking Spaces Provided 156 VARIANCES REQUESTED: 1) Driveway Ord. No. 634, as amended, Section 5.2.d requires a minimum stacking depth of 75’. A variance is requested to allow a stacking depth of approximately 40’ for all three driveways. A variance was approved with the previous site plan (ZA99-009) to allow a stacking depth of ±40’ on all three drives. Reapproval of the variance is required since the existing use of the driveway is projected to increase in actual or proposed daily design hour volume by 20% or more. Case No. ZA21-0093 2) Driveway Ord. No. 634, as amended, Section 5.1 requires a minimum throat width of 24’. A variance is requested to allow the existing throat width of 17’4” for the center driveway to remain. A variance to allow the 17’4” throat width was approved with the previous site plan in 1999. Reapproval of the variance is required since the existing use of the driveway is projected to increase in actual or proposed daily design hour volume by 20% or more. 3) Zoning Ord. No. 480, as amended, Section 33.19 requires a 5’ sidewalk to be constructed along Lonesome Dove Ave. at the time of construction. A variance is requested to allow no sidewalk to be constructed along Lonesome Dove Ave. 4) Zoning Ordinance No. 480, Section 39.6.a requires an 8’ solid fence to be constructed where the non-residential use abuts the residentially zoned lots to the west and south. A variance is requested to allow the existing fences and vegetation to remain. The Zoning Board of Adjustment approved a variance (ZBA-313) to the fence requirement in 1999. Reapproval of the variance is required since the previously approved variance was based on the plot plan presented at the time. The Zoning Ordinance was amended in 2000 to give City Council the authority to grant a variance to the screening requirements for non- residential uses where they abut residentially zoned lots or tracts or lots having an occupied residential dwelling. ACTION NEEDED: 1) Conduct a public hearing 2) Consider approval of a Site Plan ATTACHMENTS: (A) Background Information (B) Vicinity Map (C) Revised Site Plan Review Summary No. 2, dated January 5, 2022 (D) Surrounding Property Owners Map & Responses SPIN Report Presentation Narrative Letter Variance Request Letter Plans STAFF CONTACT: Ken Baker (817) 748-8067 Richard Schell (817) 748-8602 Case No. Attachment A ZA21-0093 Page 1 BACKGROUND INFORMATION OWNER: Lonesome Dove Baptist Church APPLICANT: Kirkman Engineering PROPERTY SITUATION: 2380 Lonesome Dove Ave. (also called Lonesome Dove Rd.) LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 1R1R, Block 1, Lonesome Dove Baptist Church Addition LAND USE CATEGORY: Public/Semi-Public CURRENT ZONING: “CS” Community Service District HISTORY: - The property was annexed into the City in 1957. - The “CS” Community Service District zoning was placed on the property with the adoption of Zoning Ordinance No. 480 and the Official Zoning Map in 1989. - A Preliminary Plat (ZA95-040) for Lot 1, Block 1, Lonesome Dove Baptist Church Addition was approved May 16, 1995. - A Final Plat (ZA98-132) for Lot 1, Block 1, Lonesome Dove Baptist Church Addition was approved November 19, 1998 and filed February 8, 1999. - A Site Plan (ZA99-009) for Lonesome Dove Baptist Church to add an approximately 5,996 square foot fellowship and education building was approved March 2, 1999. - A Variance (ZBA-313) to the minimum parking requirements to allow a reduction of 14 spaces and to allow 10 spaces to be gravel and a Variance to the requirement for an 8’ solid screen on the west and south property lines abutting residential properties was approved April 15, 1999. - A Plat Revision (ZA00-055) for Lots 1R1 and 1R2, Block 1, Lonesome Dove Baptist Church Addition was approved June 20, 2000 and filed August 9, 2000. - A Specific Use Permit for the Spanish Garden School (ZA10-030) was approved December 29, 2010. - A Site Plan (ZA17-063) to add 12 parking spaces on the church property was approved October 3, 2017. - An Amended Plat (ZA20-0022) for Lots 1R1R and 1R2R, Block 1, Lonesome Dove Baptist Church Addition was approved May 20, 2020 and filed May 26, 2020. SOUTHLAKE 2035 PLAN: Consolidated Future Land Use Plan The 2035 future land use designation is Public/Semi-Public. Purpose and Definition: Public/Semi-Public areas are suitable for a wide range of public, civic, and religious uses, such as government offices and facilities, public and private schools, churches and related facilities (including parsonage and parochial schools), cemeteries, and Public Parks/Open Space uses in conjunction with these developments. Mobility & Master Thoroughfare Plan The Mobility and Master Thoroughfare Plan shows Lonesome Dove Ave. to be a local street. Adequate right of way has previously been dedicated. Case No. Attachment A ZA21-0093 Page 2 Pathways Master Plan & Sidewalk Plan The Master Pathways Plan has no recommendations for Lonesome Dove Ave. A 5’ sidewalk is required to be constructed. A variance is requested to allow no sidewalk to be constructed. TRANSPORTATION ASSESSMENT: Existing Area Road Network and Conditions The development shows three driveways onto Lonesome Dove Ave. Lonesome Dove Ave. is currently a two-lane undivided local street adjacent to the site. Traffic Impact Use Floor Area Vtpd* AM- IN AM- OUT PM- IN PM- OUT Church (560) 30,895 281 20 20 26 18 * Vehicle Trips Per Day on a Weekday * AM-In, AM-Out, PM-In and PM-Out are peak hour of generator on a weekday * Based on the ITE: Trip Generation Manual, 7th Edition Use Seats Vtpd* IN OUT Church (560) Sunday 376 572 123 114 * Vehicle Trips Per Day on a Sunday * In and Out are peak hour of generator on a Sunday * Based on the ITE: Trip Generation Manual, 7th Edition TREE PRESERVATION: There is approximately 6.1% of existing tree cover on the property and a minimum of 70% of the existing tree cover is required to be preserved. A maximum of 76.66% of the existing tree cover is proposed to be preserved. UTILITIES: There is an existing 8” water line in Lonesome Dove Ave. that serves this development. An 8’ sewer line is being extended to the property from Emerald Circle to the south. DRAINAGE: Drainage is proposed to Lonesome Dove Ave. to the east and to a proposed detention pond at the south of the property from which it will also be carried to Lonesome Dove Ave. CITIZEN INPUT: A SPIN meeting was held on December 14, 2021. Please see the meeting report attached separately. A 2035 Corridor Planning Committee meeting was not held for this project. STAFF COMMENTS: Attached is Revised Site Plan Review Summary No. 2, dated January 5, 2022. The criteria for approving a variance to Driveway Ordinance No. 634 is below: Case No. Attachment A ZA21-0093 Page 3 In granting any variance, the City Council shall determine that a literal enforcement of the regulations herein will create an unnecessary hardship or practical difficulty on the applicant, that the situation causing the unnecessary hardship is unique to the affected property an is not self- imposed, that the variance will not injure and will be wholly compatible with the use and permitted development of adjacent properties, and that the granting of the variance will be in harmony with the spirit and purpose of this ordinance. The decision of the City Council shall be final. The criteria for approving a variance to Zoning Ordinance No. 480, as amended, Section 33.19 – Sidewalk Requirements, are below: The City Council may grant a variance to this regulation where compliance would present extraordinary difficulties: i. in the use of the property or; ii. to construct due to characteristics of the development or surrounding properties. General Development Standards Applies? Comments Overlay Regulations Yes The property is in the Residential Adjacency Overlay. Building Articulation No Exempt from articulation requirements Masonry Standards No Exempt from masonry requirements Impervious Coverage Yes Complies Bufferyards Yes Complies once review comments have been addressed Interior Landscape Yes Complies once review comments have been addressed Tree Preservation Yes Tree Preservation Ordinance 585-E applies. Sidewalks Yes A 5’ sidewalk is required along Lonesome Dove Ave. A variance is requested to allow no sidewalk. Case No. Attachment B ZA21-0093 Page 1 Case No. Attachment C ZA21-0093 Page 1 REVISED SITE PLAN REVIEW SUMMARY Case No.: ZA21-0093 Review No.: Two Date of Review:01/05/22 Project Name: Site Plan – Lonesome Dove Church APPLICANT: Sachi Burlingame OWNER: Jason Stover Kirkman Engineering Lonesome Dove Baptist Church 5200 SH 121 2380 Lonesome Dove Rd. Colleyville, TX 76034 Southlake, TX 76092 Phone: (817) 488-4960 Phone: E-mail: sachi.burlingame@trustke.com E-mail: dovechurchpastor@gmail.com CITY STAFF HAS REVIEWED THE ABOVE REFERENCED PROJECT RECEIVED BY THE CITY ON 12/29/21 AND WE OFFER THE FOLLOWING STIPULATIONS. THESE STIPULATIONS ARE HEREBY MADE CONDITIONS OF SITE PLAN APPROVAL UNLESS SPECIFICALLY AMENDED BY THE CITY COUNCIL. IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS OR NEED FURTHER CLARIFICATION, PLEASE CONTACT RICHARD SCHELL AT (817) 748-8602. 1. The Site Plan must conform to the underlying zoning district and the plat. 2. Place the City case number “ZA21-0093" in the lower right corner of all plans for ease of reference. 3. Please make the following change to the Site Plan (C2.0): a. Show and label the side and rear building setback lines in accordance with the current “CS” Community Service District zoning. The required side setback on the north property line is 15’. 4. On the landscape plans, show and label the width and type of bufferyards along the west and south boundaries as they are shown and labeled on the Site Plan. 5. The proposed building is to be connected to the existing Fellowship building to the north and both buildings are to have fire sprinkler systems. The Site Plan shows that the buildings are separated by 1.7’. Please revise the plans to show that the buildings are to be connected. * The following informational comments pertain to the requirements in Driveway Ordinance No. 634, as amended). * All three driveways do not meet the minimum required stacking depth of 75’. A variance was approved with the previous site plan (ZA99-009) to allow a stacking depth of ±40’ on all three drives. The required stacking depth based on the number of parking spaces shown on the previously plan was 50’. A variance to stacking depth must be approved again with the current request due to the increase in the building area and the number of parking spaces. A variance is requested to allow a stacking depth of ±40’ on all three drives. * The center driveway does not meet the minimum required driveway throat width of 24’. A width of approximately 17’4” is shown. A variance was approved with the previous site plan (ZA99-009). A variance to throat width must be approved again with the current Case No. Attachment C ZA21-0093 Page 2 request due to the increase in the building area and the number of parking spaces. A variance is requested. * Per Zoning Ord. No. 480, as amended, Section 33.19, a 5’ sidewalk is required along Lonesome Dove Rd. A variance is requested to allow no sidewalk to be constructed. * A minimum 8’ screening device meeting the requirements of Ordinance 480, Section 39 is required along all boundaries abutting residential property. The Zoning Board of Adjustment granted a variance to this requirement in 1999 at the time the previous site plan was being processed (ZBA-313). The addition of the new sanctuary building requires reapproval of a variance to the screening requirement since the Zoning Board of Adjustment approval was based on the site plan being processed at the time. A variance is requested to allow the existing fencing and vegetation to remain as is. * The required construction materials in Masonry Ordinance No. 557-A, Section 1.b and the masonry requirements in Zoning Ordinance No. 480, as amended, Section 43, Residential Adjacency Standards, Sections 43.13.a.1 appear to not be met on each elevation. A variance to the Masonry Ordinance and to the masonry requirements in the Residential Adjacency Standards would typically be required, but these requirements are exempted by HB 2439 of 86th Legislature of the State of Texas. All materials must meet applicable building codes. * All lighting must comply with the Lighting Ordinance No. 693, as amended with regard to type of lighting, intensity, glare and spill-over. Tree Conservation/Landscape Review E-mail: kmartin@ci.southlake.tx.us Keith Martin Landscape Administrator Phone: (817) 748-8229 TREE CONSERVATION COMMENTS: 1. Please provide the existing tree cover calculations on the Tree Conservation Plan. The existing tree cover calculations consist of the total percentage of existing tree cover on the property, the total percentage of existing tree cover proposed to be removed, and the total percentage of existing tree cover proposed to be preserved. * Except as provided by subsection 7.2.b. of the Tree Preservation Ordinance, a Tree Conservation Analysis or Tree Conservation Plan shall be approved if it will preserve existing tree cover in accordance with the percentage requirements established by Table 2.0. If the property has previously received a tree permit related to development, the percentage of existing tree cover at the time the first such permit was issued shall be used to calculate the minimum existing tree cover that must be preserved under this section. Case No. Attachment C ZA21-0093 Page 3 Table 2.0 – Existing Tree Cover Preservation Requirements Percentage of existing tree cover on the entire site Minimum percentage of the existing tree cover to be preserved* 0% – 20% 70% 20.1 – 40% 60% 40.1% - 60% 50% 60.1% - 80% 40% 80.1% - 100% 30% *The minimum percentage of existing tree cover to be preserved shall exclude any area in public rights-of-way as approved by City Council. * Please be aware that all existing trees shown to be preserved on the City Council approved Tree Conservation Plan must be preserved and protected during all phases and construction of the development. Alteration or removal of any of the existing trees shown to be preserved on the approved Tree Conservation Plan is a violation of the Tree Preservation Ordinance and the zoning as approved by the Southlake City Council. Please ensure that the layout of all structures, easements, utilities, structures grading, and any other structure proposed to be constructed do not conflict with existing trees intended to be preserved. LANDSCAPE COMMENTS: 1. The proposed building exceeds both 30% of the floor area of the existing building and 5,000 square feet. New construction greater in size than 30% of the existing building or greater than 5,000 square feet shall require compliance with the Landscape Ordinance as it applies to the entire square footage of the existing building and proposed addition, and compliance with the Bufferyards Regulations within the Zoning Ordinance – Section 42. The plant quantities in the Interior Landscape and Bufferyard Summary Charts indicate compliance with the current landscape requirements. 2. A variance is requested to allow the existing fences and vegetation to remain along the south and west property lines. There is no fence requirement with a Type C bufferyard, so remove “8’ wood fence” from the south and west required and provided rows in the Bufferyard Summary Chart. 3. Label all required bufferyards by width and type on the Site Plan and Landscape Plan. West - 10’ Type ‘C’, East – none required, North – none required, South – 10’ Type ‘C’. 4. The proposed parking landscape islands in the northwest corner toward the north end of the proposed rear parking are less than than 12’ wide. Parking lot islands shall have a minimum width of 12’ back-to-back if curbed or 13’ edge-to-edge if no curb is intended and shall be equal to the length of the parking stall. 5. All parking planter islands in parking areas shall contain a minimum of one (1) canopy tree with the remaining area in shrubs, ground cover, ornamental grasses or seasonal color. Turf grass is not allowed in parking planter islands. Planter islands which have light poles for lighting the parking areas may substitute two (2) understory/accent trees for the required canopy tree. * Indicates informational comment. # Indicates required items comment. Case No. Attachment C ZA21-0093 Page 4 Public Works/Engineering Review Sandra Endy, P.E. Development Engineer Phone: (817) 748-8033 E-mail: sendy@ci.southlake.tx.us UTILITY COMMENTS: 1. The proposed fire hydrant and waterline up to the hydrant shall be a public line within a dedicated easement. Please remove the proposed fire hydrant from the 8” building fire line, or connect it prior to the double check valve. DRAINAGE COMMENTS: 2. Below is an excerpt from the most current iSWM manual, updated in April 2020. The calculated 100-year, 10-min. value is 10.02 INFORMATIONAL COMMENTS: * Submit 22”x34” civil construction plans and a completed Construction Plan Checklist to the Public Works Department through the online customer self service portal located here: CSS (cityofsouthlake.com). Please allow 15 business days for review. The plans shall conform to the most recent construction plan checklist, standard details and general notes which are located on the City’s website: http://www.cityofsouthlake.com/PublicWorks/engineeringdesign.asp * New Requirement: Provide Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) per TXR150000. The plan must include all required elements in Part III, Section F of the permit. The Environmental Coordinator will review the SWPPP. For instructions on how to complete the review of the SWPPP please refer to the Stormwater Management for Construction Sites in: https://www.cityofsouthlake.com/2237/Stormwater-Management-for-Construction-S. SWPPP shall be submitted by second review of the civil construction plans. * A Developer Agreement will be required for this development and may need to be approved by the City Council prior to any construction of public infrastructure. Construction plans for these improvements must be acceptable to Public Works prior to placing the Developer’s Agreement on the City Council agenda for consideration. *=Denotes informational comment that don’t need to be addressed until Civil Construction Submittals. Case No. Attachment C ZA21-0093 Page 5 Fire Department Review Kelly Clements Deputy Fire Chief/Fire Marshal Phone: (817) 748-8233 E-mail: kclements@ci.southlake.tx.us All previous comments have been addressed. The comments below are informational. GENERAL COMMENTS: * The required backflow protection (double check valve) for the sprinkler systems can be located on the riser if the riser is within 100 feet of the water main, measured linearly along the length of the pipe. If the riser is further than 100 feet from the main, the double check valve shall be in a vault. Riser rooms shall be a minimum of 5’X5’ if the double check is located in a vault, or a minimum of 6’X6’ if it is located on the riser. * The Fire Department Connection for the sprinkler system must be within 100 feet of a fire hydrant, and within 50 feet of fire department fire lanes on the property. (FDC location not indicated on the plans) Add FDC location, wall mount or remote connection to meet the distance requirements or add a fire hydrant. FIRE LANE COMMENTS: * Fire lanes require a minimum 30 foot inside turn radius and a minimum 54 foot outside turn radius. (Per 2018 I.F.C. Sec. 503.2.4). Fire apparatus access needs to be provided within 250 feet of all exterior portions of the perimeter of buildings on a “hose-lay” basis for sprinkled buildings and 150 feet for un-sprinkled buildings. Fire apparatus access needs to be an all-weather surface, asphalt or concrete, 24 feet wide and able to support the imposed loads of fire apparatus. (Minimum of 85,000 pounds GVW). FIRE HYDRANT COMMENTS: * Fire hydrants are required at a maximum spacing of 300 feet for commercial locations that have both un-sprinklered and sprinklered buildings. Case No. Attachment C ZA21-0093 Page 6 General Informational Comments * A SPIN meeting was held on December 14, 2021. * No review of proposed signs is intended with this site plan. A separate building permit is required prior to construction of any signs. * All mechanical equipment must be screened of view from right-of-ways and residential properties in accordance with the Zoning Ordinance No. 480, as amended. * All lighting must comply with the Lighting Ordinance No. 693, as amended. * All development must comply with the Drainage Ordinance No. 605 and the Erosion and Sediment Control Ordinance No. 946, as amended. * Development must comply with all requirements in Zoning Ordinance No. 480, Section 43, Overlay Zones except as exempted. * The applicant should be aware that prior to issuance of a building permit a a fully corrected site plan, landscape plan, irrigation plan, and building plans, must be submitted for approval and all required fees must be paid. This may include but not be limited to the following fees: Park Fee, Perimeter Street Fee, Water & Sewer Impact and Tap Fees, and related Permit Fees. * In addition to the City of Southlake impact fees, please be aware that through the wholesale water customer contract with the City of Fort Worth, all new water connections are required to pay the City of Fort Worth impact fee. The City of Fort Worth impact fee assessment is based on the final plat recordation date and building permit issuance. The applicant is encouraged to review the City of Fort Worth's assessment and collection of Impact Fees Guide to determine the fee amount. * Denotes Informational Comment Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 1 SURROUNDING PROPERTY OWNERS MAP & RESPONSES ‘ SPO # Owner Zoning Physical Address Acreage Response 1. BURT, TIMOTHY SF1-A 1400 EMERALD CIR 1.14 NR 2. PONDER TRUST REVOCABLE TRUST SF1-A 1450 EMERALD CIR 1.27 NR 3. SCHILLING, AUGUST SF1-A 1260 TAYLOR ST 0.95 O 4. DEBORAH JANSEN TRUST SF1-A 2409 TAYLOR ST 0.88 NR 5. SWAIN, GREGORY E SF1-A 2407 TAYLOR ST 1.04 O 6. MUSTELL, HEATHER A SF1-A 2405 TAYLOR ST 1.00 O 7. HOSKINS, KATHERINE SF1-A 1350 EMERALD CIR 1.20 NR 8. LONESOME DOVE HOLDINGS INC AG 2589 LONESOME DOVE AVE 0.46 NR 9. RPRL LIVING TRUST SF1-A 1490 EMERALD CIR 1.26 NR 10. SCHUG, KEVIN A SF1-A 2413 TAYLOR ST 1.09 O 11. CALLAHAN REVOCABLE TRUST SF1-A 2411 TAYLOR ST 0.97 NR 12. IDOSKI, GAZIM SF1-A 2311 LONESOME DOVE AVE 1.01 NR 13. LONESOME DOVE BAPTIST CHURCH CS 2380 LONESOME DOVE AVE 6.71 F 14. SOUTHLAKE, CITY OF RPUD 1225 MCCRAE TRL 7.99 NR 15. LONESOME DOVE BAPTIST CHURCH CS 2384 LONESOME DOVE AVE 3.88 F 16. SCHUG, KEVIN SF1-A 2415 TAYLOR ST 1.63 O Responses: F: In Favor O: Opposed To U: Undecided NR: No Response Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 2 Notices Sent within 300’: Fourteen (14) Responses Received within 300’: Six (6) – Attached Responses Received outside 300’: Nine (9) – Attached separately Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 3 Responses Received from Within the 300’ Notification Area Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 4 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 5 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 6 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 7 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 8 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 9 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 10 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 11 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 12 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 13 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 14 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 15 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 16 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 17 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 18 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 19 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 20 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 21 Case No. Attachment D ZA21-0093 Page 22 Responses Received from Outside the 300’ Notification Area See pdf of Responses Outside 300’ Notification Area attached separately.