Loading...
Item 3 - Minutes REGULAR PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MEETING AUGUST 4, 2016 LOCATION: 1400 Main Street, Southlake, Texas Work Session - Executive Conference Room, Suite 268 of Town Hall or City Council Chambers of Town Hall Regular Session - City Council Chambers of Town Hall COMMISSIONERS PRESENT : Michael Forman, Michael Springer, Daniel Kubiak, Craig Rothmeier, and Michael Smietana STAFF PRESENT: Deputy Director, Dennis Killough; Principal Planner, David Jones; Planner I, Lorrie Fletcher; Civil Engineer, Civil Engineer, Om Chhetri and Commission Secretary, Holly Blake. WORK SESSION: Item No. 1 – Call to Order: Michael Forman called the work session to order at 5:35 pm. Item No. 2 – Oath of Office: Michael Forman, Daniel Kubiak, Craig Rothmeier and Michael Smietana. Item No. 3 – Recap of City Council’s action and discussion on Planning and Zoning recommended cases. Item No. 4– Discussion of all items on tonight’s meeting agenda. Item No. 5 – Adjournment. Michael Forman adjourned the work session at 6:30 pm. REGULAR SESSION: Agenda Item No. 1 – Call to Order: Michael Forman called the regular session to order at 6:37 pm. Agenda Item No. 2 – Executive Session: A. Executive Session : Pursuant to the Open Meetings Act, Chapter 551, Texas Government Code, Sections 551.071. Refer to posted list attached hereto and Executive Session may be held, under these exceptions, at the incorporated herein. end of the Regular Session or at any time during the meeting that a need arises for the Planning and Zoning Commission to seek advice from the City Attorney as to the posted subject matter of this Planning and Zoning Commission meeting. Section 551.071: Consultation with attorney B. Reconvene: Action necessary on items discussed in Executive Session. Agenda Item No. 3 – Appointment of a Chairman of the Planning and Zoning Commission. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to appoint Michael Forman as Chairman. Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes – August 4, 2016 Page 1 of 12 Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 4: - Appointment of a Vice Chairman of the Planning and Zoning Commission. Commissioner Springer motioned to appoint Daniel Kubiak as Vice-Chairman. Motion: Springer Second: Rothmeier Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 5: - Approval of the minutes for the Planning and Zoning Commission meeting held on June 9, 2016. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to approve the minutes as presented. Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 6: - Administrative Comments. No comments. REGULAR AGENDA: Agenda Item No. 15: ZA16-059, Resolution No. 16-039, Specific Use Permit for a Mass Gathering for Southlake Carroll Dragons Homecoming Parade on property described as Grand Avenue District and Phase I, Southlake Town Square, City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas; and generally located between N. Carroll Avenue, E. Southlake Boulevard and State Highway 114, Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: "DT" SPIN Neighborhood # 8. Downtown District. PUBLIC HEARING Lorrie Fletcher, Planner I, presented Item No. 15, ZA16-059. Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 2 of 12 Julie Thannum, Assisant Superintedent for Board and Cummunity Relations, 2400 N Carroll Avenue came forward to answer any questions. Commissioner Springer asked how much is raised. Ms. Thannum stated $6,000 to $9,000 through sponsorship and fundraising. This amount is spread out to student council and student groups. Chairman Forman asked if the route will remain the same. Ms. Thannum stated yes. Commissioner Kubiak asked about the staging area. Dennis Killough stated that the staging area is not impacted by surrounding development and construction. Commissioner Kubiak asked about past events and any changes. Ms. Thannum stated that CISD works closely with staff and DPS for crowd control and safety along with clean up afterwards. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to approve ZA16-047, subject to the Staff Report, dated July 29, 2016 and Site Plan Review Summary No. 3, dated July 28, 2016 and granting all variances requested and seconded by Springer. Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 7: ZA16-047, Site Plan for The Marq Southlake Champions Club on property described as Tract 3C and portions of Tracts 3C1 and 3C1A, L.G. Hall Survey, Abstract No. 686, City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas and located at 315, 275 & 285 Shady Oaks Dr., Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: “CS” Community Service SPIN Neighborhood #7. District. This item was tabled at the June 9, 2016 Regular Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting. PUBLIC HEARING Kate Meacham, Deputy Director for Community Services presented Item No. 7, ZA16- 047. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 3 of 12 Commissioner Kubiak motioned to approve ZA16-047, subject to the Staff Report, dated July 29, 2016 and Site Plan Review Summary No. 3, dated July 28, 2016 and granting all variances requested and seconded by Springer. Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 8: ZA16-056, Site Plan for the Southlake Tennis Center on property described as Tract 1C03 and portions of Tracts 1C02 and 1B, L.G. Hall Survey, Abstract No. 686, and Lot 2R2, L.G. Hall No. 686 Addition, City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas and located at 450 W. Southlake Boulevard, Southlake, SPIN Neighborhood #7. Texas. Current Zoning: “CS” Community Service District. PUBLIC HEARING Kate Meacham, Deputy Director for Community Services presented Item No. 8, ZA16- 056. Commissioner Springer asked about the storage area and what will be stored there. Ms. Meacham stated that it would be for equipment only. Commissioner Rothmeier asked about the out building for the restrooms. Ms. Meacham stated that there are some restrooms located near the hockey court and spoke on Phase III plans for both interior and exterior restrooms. Commissioner Kubiak asked about an indoor tennis court. Ms. Meacham stated that staff is evaluating the possibility for furture but not at this time. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to approve ZA16-056, subject to the Staff Report, dated July 29, 2016 and Site Plan Review Summary No. 2, dated July 29, 2016 and granting all variances requested and seconded by Springer. Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 9:ZA16-026, Ordinance No. 480-474a, Zoning Change and Site Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 4 of 12 Plan for River Oaks Park office building on property described as Lot 7, Block 1, River Oaks Addition, an addition to the City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas, and located at 121 River Oaks Dr, Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: “S-P-2” Generalized SPIN Site Plan District. Requested Zoning: “S-P-2” Generalized Site Plan District. Neighborhood #11. PUBLIC HEARING David Jones, Principal Planner, presented Item No. 9, ZA16-026. Tom Malone, 814 Pennsylvania Avenue, Fort Worth, came forward. Mr. Malone explained the reasons for the significant changes to the site plan. Chairman Forman asked about the zoning and uses, specifically medical and asked staff about restricting medical. Mr. Malone stated that there will not be any medical uses. Chairman Forman asked staff about aerial photos showing landscaping. Mr. Jones explained the existing landscaping. Commissioner Kubiak asked about the buildable area and does it include the parking. Mr. Malone showed the buildable area and explained the parking due to the floodplain. Commissioner Kubiak asked if the applicant considered a smaller building to assist with parking and accommodate the dumpster. Mr. Malone stated that they could go with a smaller footprint and then the space would be over parked. Commissioner Kubiak talked to the applicant regarding the design of the building. Commissioner Kubiak continued to state that some response forms had come in with those concerns along with concerns about parking. Commissioner Rothmeier asked about consideration for making the footprint anything but single story. Mr. Malone stated that a single story is the best route due to cost. Chairman Forman opened the public hearing. Kevin Schmuhl, 120 River Oaks Drive, Southlake came forward to speak in opposition. Mr. Schmuhl expressed his concern about the roof top mechanical equipment and the roof design not being pitched roof. In regards to the parking, any lack of parking on the applican’ts part will affect the surrounding businesses. Mr. Schmuhl also explained that the applicant did not reach out to surrounding neighbors and this is the first that anyone had seen these plans. Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 5 of 12 Mary Grace Thoennes, 119 Jellico Circle, Southlake came forward to speak in opposition. Ms. Thoennes stated that she agreed with Mr. Schmuhl and that this is the first time any plans had been shared. The other concern is the lack of landscaping, specifically shrubbery. Ms. Thoennes also expressed her concern about the traffic, security and hours of operation along with the architecture fitting in with the surrounding businesses. Chairman Forman closed the public hearing. Chairman Forman expressed his concern that a SPIN meeting was never held prior to this meeting, especially with the extreme changes. Chairman Forman also expressed his concern about the architectural changes. Commissioner Springer agreed and added that parking is a concern and it definetly affects the surrounding businesses. Commissioner Kubiak added that the building needs to be consistent with the current development and the landscaping needs work and the dumpster needs to be located off the street and needs to meet ordinance. Commissioner Smietana agreed with the remaining Commission, specifically the architecture. Chairman Forman asked the applicant to come forward and advised the applicant as to what his options were. Mr. Malone requested to table to the August 18, 2016 meeting. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to table, ZA16-026, per the applicant’s request to the regular Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting, dated August 18, 2016 with a second from Rothmeier. Motion: Kubiak Second: Rothmeier Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 10:ZA16-044, Ordinance No. 480-439c, Zoning Change and Concept/Site Plan for Texas Digestive Disease Consultants Ambulatory Surgery Center on property described as Lot 4R, Block 5 Cornerstone Business Park, an addition to the City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas, and located at 515 S. Nolen Dr., Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: "S-P-2" Generalized Site Plan District. SPIN Neighborhood #8. Requested Zoning: "S-P-2" Generalized Site Plan District. PUBLIC HEARING Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 6 of 12 David Jones, Prinicipal Planner, presented Item No. 10, ZA16-044. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Truman McDugal, with Corgan and Associates, 401 North Houston Street, Dallas came forward. Commissioner Kubiak asked the applicant to talk more about the landscaping, specifically the north western area. Mr. McDuagl explained the landscaping plan and also stated that they were going to try and save as many trees as possible. Commissioner Kubiak stated some options for the applicant. Chairman Forman asked staff to display the aerial. Chairman Forman asked how many employees will be located here and verified the hours of operation. Mr. McDugal stated that there will be 25-30 employees with normal business hours. Commissioner Springer asked if all five treatment rooms will be running at one time. Mr. McDugal stated yes. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Commissioner Springer believes that the parking will be tight and that the development has its challenges. However, this property doesn’t have many options. Mr. McDugal stated that the doctor’s will also be working across the street which will help to elevate some traffic. Commissioner Rothmeier asked about the parking ratio in Keller and if that would be an issue for traffic and utilization of parking spaces at this facility. Mr. McDugal stated the parking ratio for Keller and how it affects this site. Commissioner Kubiak stated that this property has it’s issues but this use fits and for longterm use it fits. However, the motion needs to include more information regarding landscaping. Commissioner Smietana agrees with some of the previous comments. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to approve ZA16-044, subject to the Staff Report, dated July 28, 2016 and Plan Review Summary No. 3, dated July 28, 2016 and noting the applicant’s willingness to examine the landscape plan and enhance prior to City Council with a second from Springer. Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 7 of 12 Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 11: ZA16-049, Resolution No. 16-037, Specific Use Permit for a Residential Above Ground Cistern on property described as Lot 7, Block 3 Harbor Oaks Subdivision, an addition to the City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas and located at 1065 Harbor Haven, Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: “SF-1A” Single SPIN Neighborhood # 2. Family Residential District. PUBLIC HEARING David Jones, Principal Planner, presented Item No. 11, ZA16-049. Barbara Auyang, 1065 Harbor Haven, Southlake, came forward to answer any questions. Chairman Forman asked what the cistern would be used for. Ms. Auyang stated she wanted to save water from the well for the garden. Chairman Forman asked if this was the only one. Ms. Auyang stated yes and added that she chose green so that it would blend in with the garden and yard. Chairman Forman verified that the cistern will be located behind the large tree on the right based on the aerial photo. Chairman Forman continued to ask if it will be screened. Ms. Auyang stated that there are a lot of trees on the property and she plans to plant more around it. Commissioner Kubiak stated that language needs to be added to the motion to include landscaping to screen the cistern. Commissioner Springer asked if the applicant could bury the cistern. Ms. Auyang stated that she has talked to her contractor about that. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Chairman Forman stated that he would like to see it underground as well. Dennis Killough stated that if the cistern was underground, this application would become void. Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 8 of 12 Chairman Forman asked the applicant to come forward. Ms. Auyang stated that she would talk to her contractor again about placing the cistern underground. Chairman Forman gave Ms. Auyang her options. Commissioner Rothmeier gave additional options in regards to the model of the cistern. Ms. Auyang requested to table until August 18, 2016. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to table, ZA16-049, per the applicant’s request to the regular Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting, dated August 18, 2016 and seconded by Springer. Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 12:ZA16-053, Resolution No. 16-036, Specific Use Permit for Temporary Sales Facility in Highland Oaks on property described as Lot 3, Block 2, Highland Oaks Addition, an addition to the City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas and located at 1205 Rothschild Blvd., Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: “R-PUD” SPIN Neighborhood # 7. Residential Planned Unit Development District. PUBLIC HEARING Lorrie Fletcher, Planner I, presented Item No. 12, ZA16-053. The applicant was not present. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to table ZA16-053, due to the applicant not being present to the regular Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting, dated August 18, 2016 and seconded by Springer. Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Springer, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 13:ZA16-054, Resolution No. 16-035, Specific Use Permit for a Residential Solar Energy System on property described as Lot 8, Block 4, Chimney Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 9 of 12 Hill, an addition to the City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas and located at 1407 SPIN Northridge Drive. Current zoning: “SF-20A” Single Family Residential District. Neighborhood # 10. PUBLIC HEARING David Jones, Principal Planner, presented Item No. 13, ZA16-054. Clint Austin with Solar City, 802 Oaks Shadow Ct, Mansfield and the homeowner, Robert Sloan came forward. Chairman Forman asked the applicant if they were attempting to power the home and how many are actually needed. Mr. Austin stated that Mr. Sloan’s goal is trying to power the home 80% with solar panels. Chairman Forman expressed his concern that there are so many panels and they are visible from the street. Mr. Austin stated that since solar panels are not allowed on the front slope of homes and the panels need to be on the south and southeast of the roof plans for maximum exporsure to the sun, more panels are needed to make up the difference for 80%. Commissioner Smietana asked what does the homeowner get at 80%. Mr. Austin stated that 80% means that is what the homeowner gets offset. Mr. Sloan stated that the panels covers 80% of his power versus the grid. Chairman Forman asked if this was a maximum. Mr. Austin stated that anymore percentage the panels would be feeding back into the grid. Commissioner Rothmeier stated that based on the amount of panels and the percentage that is wanting to be achieved, the number of panels could be reduced. Commissioner Springer does not like where the panels are located and asked why there were no panels on the detached garage which would make the panels not visible. Mr. Sloan stated that the panels are located where they are for maxium capacity. Chairman Forman asked if there was anywhere else the panels could go. Mr. Austin stated no. Mr. Sloan added that he spoke to his neighbors and received HOA approval. Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 10 of 12 Chairman Forman opened the public hearing. Trevor Matheson, 902 Shadywood St., Southlake came forward to speak in support of the project. Mr. Matheson stated that he was the HOA president. Chairman Forman closed the public hearing. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to approved ZA16-054, subject to the Staff Report, dated July 29, 2016 and further noting the applicant’s willingness to present multiple options for locations of the panels, specifically an option that shows a more limited solar panel location on the north facing garage roof and one that shows more limited panels on the west side of house and seconded by Rothmeier. 4-1 Motion: Kubiak Second: Rothmeier Ayes: Kubiak, Rothmeier, Smietana and Forman Nays: Springer Abstain: None Approved: 4-1-0 Agenda Item No. 14:ZA16-055, Ordinance No. 480-719, Zoning Change and Concept Plan for 289 Pine Dr. on property described as Tract 2A, Obediah W. Knight Survey, Abstract No. 899, City of Southlake, Tarrant County, Texas, and located at 289 Pine Dr., Southlake, Texas. Current Zoning: "AG" Agricultural District. Requested Zoning: "SF-1A" Single Family Residential District. SPIN Neighborhood #9. PUBLIC HEARING David Jones, Principal Planner, presented Item No. 14, ZA16-055. Chip Read, 715 Graymore Place, Southlake came forward to represent the homeowner. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to approve ZA16-055, subject to the Staff Report, dated July 28, 2016 and Concept Plan Review Summary No. 2, dated July 28, 2016 and seconded by Smietana. Motion: Kubiak Second: Smietana Ayes: Kubiak, Rothmeier, Smietana Springer and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 11 of 12 Agenda Item No. 16: CP16-004, Ordinance No. 1075a, amendment to the City of Southlake Mobility Master Plan, an element of the Southlake 2030 Comprehensive Plan. PUBLIC HEARING David Jones, Principal Planner, presented Item No. 16, CP16-004. Commissioner Rothmeier asked for clarification on the intersection analysis. Steve Anderson, Deputy City Engineer, came forward and stated that the green ones are either currently being studied or have been studied as we have been developing. Chairman Forman opened and closed the public hearing. Commissioner Kubiak motioned to approve CP16-004, subject to the Staff Report, dated July 29, 2016 and seconded by Springer. Motion: Kubiak Second: Springer Ayes: Kubiak, Rothmeier, Smietana, Springer and Forman Nays: None Abstain: None Approved: 5-0-0 Agenda Item No. 17: Meeting Adjournment at 9:09 p.m. ______________________________ Michael Forman ATTEST: Chairman ________________________________ Holly Blake Commission Secretary Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes –August 4, 2016 Page 12 of 12